Contested Skies

Contested Skies

Mumbai’s plan to shift 14 international routes from Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport to Navi Mumbai has triggered a confrontation with Gulf airlines, including Emirates, Qatar Airways, Saudia, Oman Air and Gulf Air.

The controversy centres on destinations largely in West Asia, including Doha, Riyadh, Jeddah, Muscat, Bahrain and Kuwait. Eleven Gulf carriers, alongside Nepal Airlines, have challenged the decision by Mumbai International Airport Ltd (MIAL) not to accommodate their requested slots for the Summer 2027 schedule. They face the prospect of shifting these services to Navi Mumbai or suspending them, and argue that this amounts to arbitrary interference with established operating arrangements.

MIAL, however, has a substantial infrastructure argument. Mumbai’s existing airport is operating under severe capacity constraints, while its ageing Terminal 1 is due for redevelopment. The exercise will displace domestic passenger traffic, some of which must be accommodated at Terminal 2. The airport operator estimates that the transition could temporarily reduce annual capacity by around five million passengers.

Navi Mumbai is central to addressing the metropolitan region’s chronic aviation congestion. Delaying its integration into Mumbai’s aviation network would defeat much of the purpose for which it was built.

Yet the manner of transition matters equally; Gulf airlines have invested in established routes, schedules, ground-handling arrangements and passenger networks at Mumbai. Relocation entails additional costs and potentially duplicated infrastructure. For carriers with relatively limited Indian operations, maintaining two bases serving the same metropolitan market makes little commercial sense.

The passenger dimension is equally important. Mumbai’s Gulf traffic is sustained by business travellers, migrant workers and religious pilgrims. Saudia has raised concerns about the implications for Hajj and Umrah traffic. Relocation could inconvenience passengers. Travel time, surface connectivity and the availability of onward transport will influence whether the new airport is genuinely convenient.

MIAL argues that consolidating flights to individual destinations at one airport would reduce confusion and facilitate connections. But this does not resolve the question of who determines which airlines must move and on what terms.

Historical slot allocations, bilateral air-service agreements and the principles of fair competition cannot be brushed aside in the name of operational convenience. Nor should domestic carriers automatically enjoy precedence over foreign airlines that have helped build Mumbai’s international connectivity.

Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has suggested that Terminal 1’s redevelopment be undertaken in phases rather than through a complete shutdown. A phased approach could reduce the disruption and provide greater flexibility in accommodating airlines. Equally, carriers must recognise that Mumbai cannot indefinitely preserve the status quo at an airport already stretched to capacity.

The two airports must complement each other through a transparent and equitable transition that respects the interests of operators, airlines and passengers alike. A second airport is supposed to give a city wings, not clip those of the airlines that already fly there.