From Temple Reductionism to Religious Inclusivity

From Temple Reductionism to Religious Inclusivity

Since Independence, the governance of religious institutions in India has undergone significant changes through various legal and institutional frameworks. State governments have exerted substantial administrative control over numerous Hindu temples via departments such as Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE), Muzrai, and various Devaswom Boards. In contrast, Muslim religious endowments are managed by statutory Waqf Boards, while Christian and Sikh institutions primarily operate through their respective denominational, trust-based, and statutory structures.

This disparity raises a critical constitutional and administrative question: should the governance of religious institutions acknowledge their unique theological foundations, sectarian affiliations, customary practices, and institutional traditions, rather than imposing narrow or uniform classifications on their identities? This question has gained renewed importance following the Tamil Nadu government’s initiative to classify temples under its HR&CE Department as Agamic and non-Agamic, a process that has highlighted the interplay between religious tradition, administrative authority, and institutional autonomy.

Reducing Temple Traditions

The administration of temples by the Tamil Nadu government warrants analysis in the context of the Dravidian movement’s influence on priesthood, caste, and language. In August 2021, the DMK government led by M.K. Stalin appointed 24 non-Brahmin archakas, including five individuals from Scheduled Communities, and endorsed the use of Tamil Archana in state-managed temples. These measures build upon earlier reforms initiated by M. Karunanidhi, notably the 2006 directive permitting qualified individuals from all communities to serve as priests. Nonetheless, the recent classification of temples into Agamic and non-Agamic categories, as directed by the Madras High Court, introduces a distinct issue: the adequacy of a binary administrative framework in comprehending intricate temple traditions.

The language discourse extends this relevance beyond Tamil Nadu. In Karnataka, BJP MLC Bharathi Shetty advocated for the use of Kannada shlokas and mantras, referencing Hiremagalur Kannan, while Muzrai Minister Ramalinga Reddy indicated openness to the proposal. In Maharashtra, discussions have emerged regarding language use at the Vitthal-Rukmini Temple in Pandharpur, although no statewide initiative to replace Sanskrit with Marathi has been launched. While regional-language accessibility is undeniably beneficial, it should not serve as a means to standardise diverse ritual traditions. The nation must exercise caution: inclusion should enhance understanding and participation without compromising the autonomy of established religious practices.

The risk of categorising India’s temple traditions solely into Agamic and non-Agamic classifications becomes evident upon examining the diversity inherent within Hindu traditions. Karnataka exemplifies this complexity through the legacy of Basavanna, who is traditionally linked with the establishment of Anubhava Mantapa and the promotion of Ishtalinga Dharana. Basavanna’s focus on Ishtalinga worship and the Jangama tradition is occasionally interpreted as a rejection of Sthavara Linga worship and established Shaiva temple traditions. However, such an interpretation may neglect the broader Shaiva religious and philosophical context within which Lingayat traditions emerged.

Historical scholarship identifies significant connections between early Lingayat and Virashaiva traditions and older Shaiva currents, including Pashupata and Kalamukha traditions. The practice of Ishtalinga Dharana, with its Shaiva theological foundations and ritual significance, can be situated within a broader Shaiva Agamic context. Thus, it is misleading to consider it inherently opposed to Agamic traditions. Indeed, several Lingayat ritual practices reflect the influence of Shaiva Agamic traditions, similar to how other forms of temple worship draw upon their respective Agamas and ritual texts. Consequently, Ishtalinga worship should not be casually portrayed as an entirely unrelated or disconnected religious practice. Nor should the historical relationship between these traditions be reduced to a simplistic opposition between Ishtalinga and temple worship.

If the government deems a binary classification adequate for comprehending Hindu temples, it raises the question of why this administrative rationale should not be uniformly applied to all religious institutions within the nation. If the recognition of diversity is to be acknowledged, it should not be confined to the boundaries of a single community. Consider, for example, mosques. India already possesses statutory Waqf Boards responsible for overseeing Waqf properties and their administration. If the premise is that each religious institution must be classified and managed according to its internal diversity, should the government then establish distinct administrative boards for Sunni and Shia institutions, further differentiating them based on their respective schools of jurisprudence and traditions? Furthermore, should regional and linguistic identities be transformed into administrative categories, necessitating separate boards for Urdu-speaking and other linguistic communities? Additionally, what about the varied social identities within Muslim society, including Pasmanda communities and groups identified by social designations such as Sheikh? Would each of these distinctions necessitate a distinct government-appointed administrative structure?

The same line of reasoning can be applied to Christianity. Should the government establish distinct boards for Catholic and Protestant institutions, further subdividing them into Latin, Syro-Malabar, and Syro-Malankara Catholic traditions, as well as various Protestant denominations? Should the churches in Goa and Kerala be governed by separate state-controlled religious boards? Should priests and pastors be mandated to conduct every prayer, sermon, and religious observance in the respective regional language, regardless of the liturgical traditions of their denominations? If regional-language accessibility is mandated as an administrative principle in one religious tradition, why should it not be uniformly imposed on all others? Similarly, should the government dictate the language in which the Azan is delivered in mosques, disregarding the established Arabic liturgical formula?

These questions are not proposals for actual intervention; rather, they highlight the absurdity of allowing administrative authorities to determine the internal character of religious practices without comprehending their theological foundations. This exercise can also be extended to Sikh and Jain institutions. Should separate government boards be established for the different Sikh traditions, including the Khalsa and Namdhari communities, with their distinct institutional histories and practices? Should Jain institutions be divided into separate government-controlled administrative bodies for the Digambara and Shvetambara traditions, with further subdivisions according to their respective orders and practices? Should every difference in religious observance, philosophical interpretation, language, or institutional lineage become a separate category requiring government recognition and supervision?

The argument is not that these communities should be subjected to greater government control. Rather, it illustrates why religious diversity cannot be reduced to a bureaucratic exercise. India’s religious institutions have evolved over centuries through theological interpretation, sectarian traditions, regional customs, and institutional development. Article 26 of the Constitution acknowledges the right of religious denominations and sections thereof to manage their own affairs in matters of religion, subject to constitutional limitations. If inclusivity is genuinely the objective, the government must recognise the diversity of all religious institutions rather than selectively applying narrow classifications to one community. The solution to administrative reductionism cannot be more administrative reductionism. It must be a governance framework that respects institutional diversity, protects religious autonomy, and applies constitutional principles without discrimination.

Inclusivity on the Ground

Inclusivity must be implemented in practice rather than merely acknowledged in constitutional documents. It is well-known that governments have faced challenges in relinquishing administrative control over Hindu religious institutions, especially those with significant temple revenues and properties.

If statutory oversight and administrative boards are deemed necessary for Hindu institutions, similar community-sensitive frameworks should be considered for other religious institutions, ensuring their autonomy is not compromised.

Mosques, churches, Buddhist viharas, gurdwaras, and other places of worship warrant the same constitutional consideration. Such consistent and equitable treatment is essential to render India’s constitutional inclusivity meaningful and to establish a stronger foundation for a united Bharat.

(The writer is a Bengaluru-based author and scholar. Views personal.)