If Indian cricket fans were looking for a Friday the 13th horror story, they didn’t need Netflix. All they needed was the fourth ODI between India and New Zealand.
At Bay Oval, New Zealand delivered a crushing 244-run victory, reminding India that international cricket requires more than reputation, star power and an impressive collection of batting endorsements.
The Black Caps, trailing 2-1 in the five-match series, came out with a point to prove. India, meanwhile, seemed to have mistaken the occasion for an extended fielding practice session followed by an optional batting exercise.
Young’s Masterclass
India captain Shreyas Iyer won the toss and elected to field, anticipating a favourable chase. But New Zealand had other ideas.
Will Young was the chief architect of India’s misery, producing a superb 125 off 108 deliveries, including 14 boundaries and four sixes.
Young was given two reprieves through dropped catches and responded by making the opposition regret its generosity.
With Tim Seifert contributing 58 and Finn Allen adding 41, New Zealand eventually posted 333 in 50 overs. It was a formidable total, built on Young’s brilliance and India’s inability to capitalise on opportunities.
If Young provided the entertainment with the bat, Matt Henry ensured that the second innings became a tragedy, removing Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli and Shreyas Iyer in the opening over, leaving India reeling at 0 for 3.
For Indian supporters, it was the sort of opening over that makes one reconsider the wisdom of buying expensive television subscriptions.
The damage continued when Kyle Jamieson dismissed Ruturaj Gaikwad, leaving India four down with virtually nothing on the scoreboard. At 9 for 4, the chase was no longer a chase. It was an investigation into what had gone wrong.
With the top order back in the pavilion, Ishan Kishan and Axar Patel decided that someone needed to remember that batting was part of the game.
The pair put together a 44-run partnership, offering some much-needed resistance. Kishan made 27 while Axar contributed 21. For a brief period, there was something resembling a cricket innings taking place.
Matt Fisher broke the stand by dismissing Axar, and Henry returned to remove Kishan. The rescue operation was officially declared unsuccessful.
Naman Dhir chipped in with a spirited 21, including two consecutive sixes, presumably to remind everyone that Indian batters still knew where the boundary was. But his resistance was short-lived.
Fisher finished with three wickets, while Henry completed a devastating six-wicket haul for 27 runs. India were eventually dismissed for 89 in 26.4 overs.
The margin of defeat was 244 runs. It was India’s sixth-lowest ODI total and their second-biggest defeat in terms of runs in the format.
Henry’s opening-over destruction and eventual figures of 6/27 earned him the Player of the Match award. New Zealand were disciplined with the ball, sharp in the field and ruthless when opportunities presented themselves. India, by contrast, appeared to have misplaced their instruction manual for playing against quality pace bowling.
The victory keeps New Zealand alive in the five-match series, although India still lead 2-1.
For India, however, the defeat raises uncomfortable questions. The absence of Shubman Gill and KL Rahul, who are preparing for the upcoming Test series, was a factor, but it cannot entirely explain the batting implosion.
A team aspiring to dominate international cricket cannot afford to surrender three of its biggest batting names for ducks in a single opening over. Nor can it expect to chase 334 when its top order treats the opposition’s bowling attack like an evacuation announcement.
India need to regroup, reassess their approach against quality pace bowling and perhaps spend some time in the nets practising the rather underrated art of staying at the crease.
New Zealand, meanwhile, deserve every bit of credit. They played fearless, intelligent cricket and exposed India’s vulnerabilities with clinical precision.
Friday the 13th has a reputation for bad luck. But there was nothing particularly unlucky about India’s performance. New Zealand earned this victory, wicket by wicket, delivery by delivery.
And somewhere in the Indian dressing room, one suspects, the batters were already looking forward to Sunday. Not necessarily to bat again. Perhaps just to put this Friday behind them.
Because when you lose by 244 runs, the post-match discussion is about who remembered to bring the batting line-up in the first place.
(The writer is a senior journalist based in Mumbai. Views personal.)
