The Loyalty Trap: When Belonging Becomes Captivity

The Loyalty Trap: When Belonging Becomes Captivity

Some people spend half their lives complaining about the institutions where they work. They criticise the management, question its decisions and recall occasions when they were treated unfairly. Yet the moment an outsider makes the same criticism, they rush to defend the institution. They may have considered leaving several times, but somehow never do. Even after retirement, what happens there continues to bother them. Why do we become so attached to institutions that repeatedly disappoint us?

This is particularly common in universities and research laboratories, where people spend decades building something they deeply value. A scientist may dislike how an institution is run but remain fiercely proud of belonging to it. A teacher may feel neglected by a university yet speak of it with great affection. Such contradictions raise an uncomfortable question: can loyalty become so deeply rooted that we gradually lose the freedom to question, disagree or walk away?


The Belonging Delusion
A workplace is rarely just a place where we earn a living. Over the years, it becomes associated with friendships, achievements, disappointments and memories. We begin to introduce ourselves through our institutions. Their reputation becomes part of our reputation. Their successes feel like our successes, and criticism of them can feel strangely personal.
Psychologists call this organisational identification. The term sounds complicated, but the experience is familiar. We gradually begin to think of an institution as part of who we are. This attachment can be healthy. It encourages cooperation, pride and a willingness to contribute beyond the demands of a job. Problems arise when belonging becomes so important that we hesitate to acknowledge what is wrong.


Sometimes, relationships at work become more troubling. In abusive personal relationships, people may develop strong attachments to those who mistreat them, particularly when harsh behaviour is occasionally followed by kindness or praise. Psychologists call this trauma bonding. Certain relationships between powerful supervisors and dependent employees may show similar patterns. However, ordinary loyalty to a difficult workplace should not be confused with trauma bonding.]


Consider a young researcher whose supervisor frequently humiliates him but occasionally offers praise or promises an important opportunity. The researcher may work harder, hoping to regain approval rather than questioning the treatment. Gradually, the need for recognition can become stronger than the willingness to speak up. What began as a professional relationship may turn into an unhealthy dependence on someone else’s approval.
The longer we stay, the harder leaving can become. After spending twenty or thirty years building a laboratory or department, moving elsewhere may feel like abandoning part of ourselves. We may continue investing time and energy simply because we have already invested so much. Yet the years spent somewhere cannot be recovered by staying longer. What matters is whether remaining there still offers purpose, dignity and opportunities to grow.


Of course, people remain in difficult workplaces for many legitimate reasons. Financial security, family responsibilities, limited alternatives and concern for students or colleagues all matter. Some stay because they believe they can bring about change. The real question is whether they remain by choice or because fear, guilt or the need for approval has made leaving seem impossible.
Loyalty is not only about what individuals feel towards institutions. It is also about what institutions owe those who serve them. People give their workplaces years of effort, commitment and creativity. In return, they deserve fairness, respect and the support needed to do their jobs well. Problems arise when this relationship becomes one-sided.


Imagine a professor whose laboratory lacks essential equipment. Rather than disappoint her students, she borrows instruments, spends her own money and works late into the evening. Her students complete their experiments and publish papers. The university proudly celebrates their achievements. Yet the laboratory remains poorly equipped. The professor has done something admirable. Her students have benefited, and research has continued. But has her dedication also made it easier for the university to ignore its shortcomings?
Here lies a paradox. The most dedicated employees may unintentionally help conceal the very institutional weaknesses they struggle to overcome. When committed people repeatedly find ways around inadequate facilities, delayed decisions and poor administration, the institution continues functioning. Its achievements remain visible, while the extraordinary effort behind them often goes unnoticed.
Gradually, exceptional sacrifice becomes an everyday expectation. Those who work beyond their limits are praised for their commitment, but the conditions that make such efforts necessary remain unchanged. This does not always happen because leaders deliberately exploit employees. Sometimes problems persist because money is scarce, priorities are misplaced or nobody feels enough pressure to act.


The Sacrifice Paradox
This deserves attention in Indian higher education. We often celebrate the number of papers published, projects completed and students trained, but rarely ask how much unnecessary effort was required to achieve these results. The ability of teachers and researchers to overcome difficulties deserves praise. Yet their dedication should not become an excuse for institutions to avoid improvement.


Many great scientific institutions were built through extraordinary personal sacrifice. Such commitment deserves admiration. But there is a difference between accepting hardship to build something worthwhile and enduring the same hardship indefinitely because nothing improves. Responsibility for correcting institutional weaknesses rests with those entrusted with running institutions, not with the people struggling to keep them functioning.
This is particularly troubling in universities, where questioning accepted ideas is supposed to be a virtue. Scientific progress depends on curiosity, evidence and the courage to challenge established beliefs. How can an institution encourage independent thinking in classrooms and laboratories while discouraging it when administrative decisions are questioned?


There is an inherent contradiction in celebrating intellectual independence while expecting unquestioning institutional allegiance. A researcher who challenges a scientific theory is considered courageous; one who questions an administrative decision may be labelled difficult or disloyal. Yet both acts can arise from the same intellectual instinct: the willingness to examine what others take for granted.
Institutions that suppress criticism may enjoy an appearance of harmony, but silence is not the same as agreement. When people stop questioning, problems do not disappear. They simply become harder to see and more expensive to correct.


Perhaps we need to change how we judge loyalty. Spending an entire career in one institution does not necessarily mean someone was happy or fulfilled. Nor does leaving mean that a person has been disloyal. What matters is whether people were treated fairly, allowed to grow and given the freedom to disagree without fear.


A good institution should value dedication without taking advantage of it. It should listen to criticism, correct its weaknesses and give people reasons to stay. There is also a responsibility on individuals to recognise the difference between commitment and dependence. We can cherish the friendships, memories and achievements associated with an institution without defending every decision it makes. We can be grateful for opportunities received while remaining honest about its shortcomings.


Above all, we must understand that our professional identity need not be held hostage by the organisation with which we happen to be associated. Institutions, too, must recognise that criticism is not necessarily an act of betrayal. Often, those who question an organisation most persistently are the very people who care deeply about its future. Their dissent may be uncomfortable, but it can be an important source of renewal. Institutional loyalty should be measured by the quality of the relationship between the institution and its people. A good institution earns people’s loyalty. It does not make them feel guilty for leaving.

 

Some people spend half their lives complaining about the institutions where they work. They criticise the management, question its decisions and recall occasions when they were treated unfairly. Yet the moment an outsider makes the same criticism, they rush to defend the institution. They may have considered leaving several times, but somehow never do. Even after retirement, what happens there continues to bother them. Why do we become so attached to institutions that repeatedly disappoint us?


This is particularly common in universities and research laboratories, where people spend decades building something they deeply value. A scientist may dislike how an institution is run but remain fiercely proud of belonging to it. A teacher may feel neglected by a university yet speak of it with great affection. Such contradictions raise an uncomfortable question: can loyalty become so deeply rooted that we gradually lose the freedom to question, disagree or walk away?
The Belonging Delusion
A workplace is rarely just a place where we earn a living. Over the years, it becomes associated with friendships, achievements, disappointments and memories. We begin to introduce ourselves through our institutions. Their reputation becomes part of our reputation. Their successes feel like our successes, and criticism of them can feel strangely personal.


Psychologists call this organisational identification. The term sounds complicated, but the experience is familiar. We gradually begin to think of an institution as part of who we are. This attachment can be healthy. It encourages cooperation, pride and a willingness to contribute beyond the demands of a job. Problems arise when belonging becomes so important that we hesitate to acknowledge what is wrong.
Sometimes, relationships at work become more troubling. In abusive personal relationships, people may develop strong attachments to those who mistreat them, particularly when harsh behaviour is occasionally followed by kindness or praise. Psychologists call this trauma bonding. Certain relationships between powerful supervisors and dependent employees may show similar patterns. However, ordinary loyalty to a difficult workplace should not be confused with trauma bonding.


Consider a young researcher whose supervisor frequently humiliates him but occasionally offers praise or promises an important opportunity. The researcher may work harder, hoping to regain approval rather than questioning the treatment. Gradually, the need for recognition can become stronger than the willingness to speak up. What began as a professional relationship may turn into an unhealthy dependence on someone else’s approval.


The longer we stay, the harder leaving can become. After spending twenty or thirty years building a laboratory or department, moving elsewhere may feel like abandoning part of ourselves. We may continue investing time and energy simply because we have already invested so much. Yet the years spent somewhere cannot be recovered by staying longer. What matters is whether remaining there still offers purpose, dignity and opportunities to grow.
Of course, people remain in difficult workplaces for many legitimate reasons. Financial security, family responsibilities, limited alternatives and concern for students or colleagues all matter. Some stay because they believe they can bring about change. The real question is whether they remain by choice or because fear, guilt or the need for approval has made leaving seem impossible.
Loyalty is not only about what individuals feel towards institutions. It is also about what institutions owe those who serve them. People give their workplaces years of effort, commitment and creativity. In return, they deserve fairness, respect and the support needed to do their jobs well. Problems arise when this relationship becomes one-sided.


Imagine a professor whose laboratory lacks essential equipment. Rather than disappoint her students, she borrows instruments, spends her own money and works late into the evening. Her students complete their experiments and publish papers. The university proudly celebrates their achievements. Yet the laboratory remains poorly equipped. The professor has done something admirable. Her students have benefited, and research has continued. But has her dedication also made it easier for the university to ignore its shortcomings?
Here lies a paradox. The most dedicated employees may unintentionally help conceal the very institutional weaknesses they struggle to overcome. When committed people repeatedly find ways around inadequate facilities, delayed decisions and poor administration, the institution continues functioning. Its achievements remain visible, while the extraordinary effort behind them often goes unnoticed.


Gradually, exceptional sacrifice becomes an everyday expectation. Those who work beyond their limits are praised for their commitment, but the conditions that make such efforts necessary remain unchanged. This does not always happen because leaders deliberately exploit employees. Sometimes problems persist because money is scarce, priorities are misplaced or nobody feels enough pressure to act.


The Sacrifice Paradox
This deserves attention in Indian higher education. We often celebrate the number of papers published, projects completed and students trained, but rarely ask how much unnecessary effort was required to achieve these results. The ability of teachers and researchers to overcome difficulties deserves praise. Yet their dedication should not become an excuse for institutions to avoid improvement.
Many great scientific institutions were built through extraordinary personal sacrifice. Such commitment deserves admiration. But there is a difference between accepting hardship to build something worthwhile and enduring the same hardship indefinitely because nothing improves. Responsibility for correcting institutional weaknesses rests with those entrusted with running institutions, not with the people struggling to keep them functioning.


This is particularly troubling in universities, where questioning accepted ideas is supposed to be a virtue. Scientific progress depends on curiosity, evidence and the courage to challenge established beliefs. How can an institution encourage independent thinking in classrooms and laboratories while discouraging it when administrative decisions are questioned?
There is an inherent contradiction in celebrating intellectual independence while expecting unquestioning institutional allegiance. A researcher who challenges a scientific theory is considered courageous; one who questions an administrative decision may be labelled difficult or disloyal. Yet both acts can arise from the same intellectual instinct: the willingness to examine what others take for granted.
Institutions that suppress criticism may enjoy an appearance of harmony, but silence is not the same as agreement. When people stop questioning, problems do not disappear. They simply become harder to see and more expensive to correct.


Perhaps we need to change how we judge loyalty. Spending an entire career in one institution does not necessarily mean someone was happy or fulfilled. Nor does leaving mean that a person has been disloyal. What matters is whether people were treated fairly, allowed to grow and given the freedom to disagree without fear.


A good institution should value dedication without taking advantage of it. It should listen to criticism, correct its weaknesses and give people reasons to stay. There is also a responsibility on individuals to recognise the difference between commitment and dependence. We can cherish the friendships, memories and achievements associated with an institution without defending every decision it makes. We can be grateful for opportunities received while remaining honest about its shortcomings.


Above all, we must understand that our professional identity need not be held hostage by the organisation with which we happen to be associated. Institutions, too, must recognise that criticism is not necessarily an act of betrayal. Often, those who question an organisation most persistently are the very people who care deeply about its future. Their dissent may be uncomfortable, but it can be an important source of renewal. Institutional loyalty should be measured by the quality of the relationship between the institution and its people. A good institution earns people’s loyalty. It does not make them feel guilty for leaving.

(The writer is an ANRF Prime Minister Professor at COEP Technological University, Pune, and former Director of the Agharkar Research Institute, Pune. Views personal.)