top of page

By:

Correspondent

23 August 2024 at 4:29:04 pm

Broken Faith

For generations, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement was about far more than bricks and mortar. It was sustained by faith, sacrifice and an unwavering belief among millions of devotees that one day a grand temple would rise at what they regarded as the birthplace of Lord Ram. After decades of political battles, social upheaval and legal contestation, that dream finally became reality. For countless Hindus, it marked the fulfilment of a civilisational aspiration. This is precisely why the allegations...

Broken Faith

For generations, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement was about far more than bricks and mortar. It was sustained by faith, sacrifice and an unwavering belief among millions of devotees that one day a grand temple would rise at what they regarded as the birthplace of Lord Ram. After decades of political battles, social upheaval and legal contestation, that dream finally became reality. For countless Hindus, it marked the fulfilment of a civilisational aspiration. This is precisely why the allegations now emerging from Ayodhya are so disturbing. The Special Investigation Team constituted by the Uttar Pradesh government is probing serious irregularities in the handling of donations offered by devotees, to the tune of Rs. 7-7.5 crores missing. Investigators are examining the procedures governing donation boxes, cash counting and the movement of personnel entrusted with handling offerings made in good faith by worshippers. The details are deeply troubling. Individuals involved in counting donations are under scrutiny for sudden and unexplained financial growth. Authorities have allegedly recovered substantial sums of cash. Questions are being asked about assets accumulated by persons linked to temple operations. When a devotee places money into a donation box, it is an act of faith. The offering is made not to an institution but to the deity. Those entrusted with managing such offerings carry a responsibility far greater than that borne by ordinary administrators. They are custodians of sacred trust. The allegations that have emerged have wounded the emotional bond that millions have forged with the temple. While a scandal in a government department is unfortunate, a scandal involving a sacred institution is even more corrosive. It risks breeding cynicism where reverence should exist. The Ram Mandir is too important an institution to be shielded from scrutiny. In fact, because of its significance, it must be subjected to higher standards of transparency than almost any other public body in the country. While the temple itself remains a symbol of faith, what requires examination are the actions of those entrusted with managing a sacred institution. For years, devotees contributed money, labour and emotional energy to a cause they believed transcended politics. They did not do so to enrich temple employees or power brokers. The SIT investigation must therefore proceed without fear or favour. Every allegation must be examined. Every financial trail must be followed. Every individual, regardless of proximity to powerful figures, must be held accountable if wrongdoing is established. The Ram Mandir was built through the devotion of millions. Its sanctity cannot be compromised by the greed of a few. The greatest threat to the temple today does not come from outside its walls. It comes from the possibility that those entrusted with protecting faith may have betrayed it. And for devotees, that is the most painful betrayal of all.

Defying a Hostile World

While India’s consumption-led economy is holding the fort against a hostile world, the ongoing trade war will test the depth of that resilience.

The year 2025 was not kind to the world economy. War, tariffs and geopolitical one-upmanship tore through supply chains and spooked capital. Yet India, buffeted though it was by these storms, sailed on with surprising steadiness. Services exports kept surging, merchandise trade expanded in patches, and, most importantly, the vast engine of domestic consumption kept humming. If India’s growth story has a single protagonist, it is no longer the foreign buyer but the Indian consumer.


Private Final Consumption Expenditure, or PFCE, remains the best barometer of that consumer’s mood. The two years after Covid saw a frenzy of ‘revenge shopping’ as households splurged on everything from appliances to air travel. Economists expected that sugar rush to fade. It did flatten for a while in early FY 2025. But by the final quarter of that year, consumption growth was running again at around seven percent, a pace repeated in the first quarter of FY 2026 and then exceeded in the second, which clocked a robust 7.9 percent. Three forces explain the revival. Cooling inflation lifted real incomes. New tax slabs introduced in April 2025 put more cash in middle-class pockets. And goods and services tax cuts announced in September fattened disposable incomes further.


Not Uniform

The recovery, however, has been anything but uniform. Rural India has been doing the heavy lifting. Strong harvests, generous minimum support price announcements and healthy kharif output, coupled with encouraging rabi sowing, have bolstered farm incomes. That has translated directly into demand for fast-moving consumer goods, where rural volumes are now outpacing urban ones. Even quick-commerce platforms are spreading into smaller towns and villages, amplifying the effect.


Urban India, by contrast, spent much of mid-2025 in the doldrums. Wage growth lagged the rise in housing and food costs, sapping discretionary spending. Only when tax relief, GST cuts and easier monetary policy coincided with the festive season did city shoppers return to showrooms.


This pattern matters because India’s headline growth numbers in the first half of FY 2026 - quarterly expansion of about 8.2 percent even as the world economy convulsed - were powered overwhelmingly by demand at home. That carries big implications. It suggests India is completing a structural shift away from export-led growth towards a consumption-driven model more typical of large emerging economies. It gives policymakers room to cut rates and offer tax relief without immediately stoking inflation. And it means that, up to a point, external shocks can be absorbed without wrenching domestic adjustment. The caveat is obvious. If tariffs and trade wars start destroying jobs, consumption will not stay insulated for long.


The contradictions of India’s external sector were on full display in 2025. Merchandise exports between April and November rose a modest 2.62 percent year-on-year to USD 292.07 billion, but November alone surged by over 19 percent. Electronics led the charge, with shipments in September jumping by more than 50 percent and November recording close to 39 percent growth. Drugs and pharmaceuticals grew by about 21 percent, helped by explicit American tariff exemptions for medical products. Even petroleum products rose by around 12 percent, reflecting both global prices and India’s growing role as a regional refining hub.


Imports, however, ran even faster. They grew 5.7 percent to USD 515.21 billion, pushing the trade deficit to USD 223.13 billion, about 43 percent of total goods trade. October was spectacular, with imports hitting a record USD 76.06 billion, largely because gold purchases soared to USD 14.72 billion, nearly three times the previous year. That frenzy reflected both record global prices and domestic efforts to hedge against a weakening rupee.


Structural Dependencies

The import bill also reveals India’s structural dependencies. Petroleum still accounts for roughly 27 percent of imports, with crude oil covering almost 80 percent of consumption. Precious metals and stones make up about 14 percent. Some of the recent surge also owed to inventory-building ahead of American tariff hikes in late August.


Against this backdrop, services exports were the star performer. From April to November, they rose 8.65 percent to USD 270.06 billion, while services imports were only USD 135.93 billion, leaving a hefty surplus of USD 134.13 billion. November alone saw exports jump nearly 12 percent. India’s edge in information technology, business-process outsourcing, finance and professional services remains formidable, providing a steady stream of foreign earnings that cushions the volatility of goods trade.


That cushion is badly needed. In one of the harshest geopolitical blows in years, the United States slapped a sweeping 50 percent tariff on Indian goods in 2025, making India the hardest-hit major American trading partner. Because the move was framed around India’s purchases of Russian oil rather than simple trade balances, it is politically harder to unwind. Roughly 55 percent of India’s exports to America have been affected. Textiles have been devastated, with volumes to the United States worth USD 10.3 billion down by about 70 percent as buyers switch to cheaper Southeast Asian suppliers. Leather is in similar trouble. Pharmaceuticals, electronics and engineering goods, blessed with lower tariffs, have fared much better.


India has tried to compensate by pivoting to other markets. Free-trade agreements with Britain, Switzerland and New Zealand, and expanded pacts with the United Arab Emirates and the European Free Trade Association, offer new outlets. The UK deal alone, signed in July 2025, could add USD 6.4–7 billion in annual trade, helping textile exporters tap Commonwealth markets. But none of these can fully replace lost American demand.


Hence a hefty domestic response. On November 12, the government unveiled an export-support package worth Rs 45,000 crore, or about USD 5.1 billion, spread over six years. At the same time, it is accelerating trade diplomacy, even seeking to coordinate with China and members of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership.


The full pain of America’s tariffs has yet to be felt. Pre-tariff stockpiling softened the initial blow. But as 2026 unfolds, job losses in vulnerable sectors may start to bite. India cannot simply shrug off the threat, nor can it accept trade terms dictated from Washington. How the coming Union Budget deploys relief, stimulus and reform will go a long way towards deciding whether the country’s domestic defiance can outlast a very unfriendly world.


(The author is a Chartered Accountant with a leading company in Mumbai. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page