top of page

By:

Dr. Keshav Kumar & Hemanth Sai Reddy

19 June 2025 at 2:30:46 pm

Beyond the ‘Truth Serum’

Narcoanalysis is often sensationalised as a “truth serum”, but in reality, it is a scientific investigative aid grounded in neuroscience and forensic psychology. In an era where crime has become increasingly sophisticated, law-enforcement agencies are compelled to rely on science as much as instinct. Among the most debated tools in this scientific arsenal is narcoanalysis, often sensationalised as a “truth serum” test. While critics question its ethics and reliability, narcoanalysis, when...

Beyond the ‘Truth Serum’

Narcoanalysis is often sensationalised as a “truth serum”, but in reality, it is a scientific investigative aid grounded in neuroscience and forensic psychology. In an era where crime has become increasingly sophisticated, law-enforcement agencies are compelled to rely on science as much as instinct. Among the most debated tools in this scientific arsenal is narcoanalysis, often sensationalised as a “truth serum” test. While critics question its ethics and reliability, narcoanalysis, when applied lawfully and scientifically, has proved to be a valuable investigative aid, particularly in complex and deadlocked cases. Narcoanalysis involves the controlled administration of barbiturates such as sodium pentothal (sodium thiopental), sodium amytal, or similar drugs that depress the central nervous system. These substances induce a semi-conscious state in which higher cognitive inhibitions are lowered. The scientific premise rests on neuroscience and psychology: when cortical control is suppressed, a subject becomes less guarded, allowing spontaneous verbalisation of memories that may be consciously suppressed during conventional interrogation. Trained forensic psychologists, assisted by anaesthesiologists, conduct questioning in this altered mental state, ensuring medical safety and procedural discipline. From a neural and philosophical standpoint, narcoanalysis recognises the layered nature of human cognition. Memory is not always accessible through conscious recall; fear, guilt, or trauma often block truthful disclosure. By chemically reducing mental resistance, narcoanalysis can allow access to subconscious recollections. India’s experience with narcoanalysis includes several high-profile criminal investigations. In the Nithari serial killings case, narcoanalysis of the accused reportedly helped investigators reconstruct timelines and locate corroborative evidence when the probe had reached a standstill. Similarly, during the Telgi fake stamp paper scam, narcoanalysis was used to unravel the scale of the conspiracy and identify critical links, leading to further recoveries and arrests. In cases involving organised crime and terrorism, the technique has often served as a breakthrough mechanism. The judiciary has acknowledged this investigative utility while firmly drawing constitutional boundaries. In Selvi & Ors. v. State of Karnataka (2010) ,  the Supreme Court held that   involuntary narcoanalysis is unconstitutional, as it violates the right against self-incrimination under Article 20(3) and the right to personal liberty under Article 21. However, the judgement did not discard narcoanalysis altogether. Instead, it carved out a lawful space for its voluntary use, subject to strict safeguards. The Court clarified that narcoanalysis may be conducted only with the free, informed consent of the subject,   recorded before a judicial magistrate, with access to legal counsel and full disclosure of medical and legal consequences. Crucially, while statements made during narcoanalysis are not admissible as evidence ,  the court recognised that facts discovered as a result of such statements may be admissible, provided they are independently verified. Thus, if narcoanalysis leads to the discovery of a weapon, location, or material fact, and such discovery is corroborated independently, it can assume evidentiary value not because of the statement itself, but because of the factual discovery it enables. Indian courts have, on occasion, acknowledged the relevance of scientific interrogation techniques. The Bombay High Court, in cases such as  Ramchandra Ram Reddy v. State of Maharashtra , emphasises narcoanalysis and related forensic tests as necessary modern investigative tools, provided they are conducted ethically, scientifically, and under judicial oversight. While courts remain cautious, there is judicial appreciation of science-led investigation when constitutional safeguards are respected. Institutions such as the Directorate of Forensic Science Services (DFS) and Gujarat FSL have further strengthened the credibility of narcoanalysis by developing it within a forensic psychology framework, adhering to international medical and ethical standards. Their work demonstrates that narcoanalysis, when conducted by experts rather than interrogators, can align with both science and law. Narcoanalysis is neither a magic wand nor a mediaeval coercive practice. It is a scientific investigative aid, meant to supplement—not supplant—traditional evidence. Used voluntarily, cautiously, and professionally, it can illuminate investigative paths otherwise hidden. In the balance between civil liberties and societal interest in justice, narcoanalysis deserves not dismissal but disciplined acceptance within the rule of law.   (Kumar is a former IPS officer and forensic consultant to Assam government. Reddy is Forensic Psychologist & Corporate Security & Loss Prevention Executive. Views personal.)

Growing Risks Of Cyber Warfare

Updated: Oct 21, 2024

In a shocking series of events, multiple coordinated explosions have rocked Lebanon and parts of Syria, killing dozens of people and injuring thousands. The blasts occurred after explosive devices, hidden inside pagers and other radio communication devices, were detonated. The targeted individuals were primarily members of Hezbollah, with the explosions taking place in densely populated areas, resulting in widespread injuries to civilians, including children.

The devices, mainly pagers, walkie-talkies, and radios, had been in the possession of Hezbollah operatives, who had acquired them months prior, under the assumption they were secure. However, Hezbollah has accused Israel’s intelligence agency, Shin Bet, of tampering with the devices during transit.

According to security experts, Israel’s elite secret cyber warfare unit was behind the attack. This unit, known for its global cyber operations, is also linked to the creation of the STUXnet malware, which was responsible for the failure of Iran’s nuclear power plant. The pagers were rigged with explosive materials in place of a battery, and a relay switch was installed, allowing the explosions to be triggered remotely in a synchronized manner. The result was devastating injuries to the eyes, face, hands, and legs of those carrying the devices.

The incident occurred in Hezbollah-stronghold areas, including the Dahieh suburb of Beirut, southern Lebanon, and parts of the Beqaa Valley, with some explosions also reported across the border in Syria. The blasts overwhelmed hospitals, as hundreds of victims sought medical help for injuries ranging from severe burns to shattered limbs. The intensity of the explosions, far beyond that of ordinary battery malfunctions, indicates a highly sophisticated sabotage operation.

These explosions have not only deepened the crisis in Lebanon but have also raised critical questions about supply chain security, intelligence tactics, and the legality of using booby-trapped electronics in conflict zones.


What Are Pagers, and Why Are They Still Preferred?

Despite being old-school tele communication technology, pagers or beepers are still used in many countries, particularly in critical sectors and organizations. Pagers primarily facilitate one-way communication, pager uses higher frequencies than car radios i.e. 400 MHz band frequency. It also used a very basic type of VHF spectrum. These devices operate in restricted areas to transfer messages, alerts, and information. These devices are considered more secure and harder to trace or track compared to mobile phones, as they only receive messages, similar to a car radio that receives signals without revealing the listener’s identity or location. Additionally, pagers lack features like Bluetooth or GPS, making them more difficult to hack or compromise.

Among their many advantages, pagers are known for their long battery life and durability, making them ideal for continuous use in specific industries. There are an estimated two million active pager users worldwide. Hezbollah began using pagers after Israel successfully assassinated a high-ranking Hezbollah target by hacking his cellphone and precisely targeting him with a missile. Since then, many Hezbollah members have switched to more primitive communication devices, like pagers, to avoid being tracked via the internet.


Are Mobile Phones and Smartphones Similarly Vulnerable?

American and European security agencies suggest that, theoretically, it is possible to alter mobile phones and other smart devices to turn them into explosive devices. However, practically, it is more difficult due to the advanced security systems in modern smartphones. A hacked smartphone may exhibit various signs, such as abnormal temperature changes, slower system performance, unexpected reboots, odd sounds during calls, hung applications, or irrelevant messages and pop-ups, all of which could indicate tampering. These security systems make it more challenging to modify smartphones in the same manner as simpler devices like pagers.


New Security Challenges

The Hezbollah pager explosion serves as a wake-up call for sectors involving critical infrastructure and aviation. In an era where smartphones are network-connected and can be charged wirelessly, the possibility of tampering with batteries or embedding explosives, like HMX, PETN and other type of plastic explosives pose significant risks. During flights, even a minor explosion could result in catastrophic consequences. On the ground, the threat extends to damaging nearby aircraft, equipment, and infrastructure. Airport security may soon impose stricter regulations, potentially banning pagers, walkie-talkies, and radios, much like power banks, which are now restricted on flights. In the future, mobile phones may only be allowed in switched-off modes, placed in lithium-safe bags during flights. Suspicious devices could be handled separately in Faraday-sheet bags to block any network or signal connections.

This incident highlights the growing risks of cyber warfare and the dangers posed by everyday communication devices being exploited for sabotage. It is an alarming call for a nation’s security as the treat of such critical infrastructure being handled by terrorist organisations can compromise the use of day-to-day electronics for malicious activities. As technology advances, so must the protocols for ensuring public safety, particularly in high-risk environments where even the smallest vulnerability could lead to devastating consequences.

(The writer is an eminent cyber and explosives forensic expert. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page