top of page

By:

Quaid Najmi

4 January 2025 at 3:26:24 pm

Modi’s ‘Melody’ diplomacy stuns the world

Overjoyed investors buy shares of a wrong company after the PM’s gift Mumbai: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday gifting his Italian counterpart Giorgia Meloni 'Melody' toffees, reviving the light-hearted "Melodi" wordplay associated with the two leaders on social media. Meloni thanked Modi and shared a video on the social media in which she could be heard saying, “Prime Minister Modi brought as a gift, a very, very good toffee - Melody.” Modi, who was also seen in the video, burst...

Modi’s ‘Melody’ diplomacy stuns the world

Overjoyed investors buy shares of a wrong company after the PM’s gift Mumbai: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday gifting his Italian counterpart Giorgia Meloni 'Melody' toffees, reviving the light-hearted "Melodi" wordplay associated with the two leaders on social media. Meloni thanked Modi and shared a video on the social media in which she could be heard saying, “Prime Minister Modi brought as a gift, a very, very good toffee - Melody.” Modi, who was also seen in the video, burst into laughter as Meloni jokingly referred to the "Melody" toffee while showcasing the gift. The hashtag "Melodi", a blend of Modi and Meloni's names, was coined by the Italian prime minister during the COP28 in Dubai in 2023 and later went viral on social media following the warm interactions between the two leaders at global events. Modi, who arrived in Rome on Tuesday, is on the final leg of his five-nation tour to the UAE, the Netherlands, Sweden, Norway and Italy from May 15-20. Modi’s gift not only floored the social media, but also earned gushing gratitude from the manufacturer of the sweet candy, Parle Products, in Vile Parle, Mumbai. “Thank You. Hon’ble Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi for taking Parle Melody to the global stage. A proud moment for all of us at Parle Products to see an Indian favourite being shared across borders,” said a social media post from @ParleFamily, a 97-year-old company. Parle Products describes Melody: “Parle Melody brings to you an irresistible layer of caramel on the outside & a delightful chocolate filling inside. Open & pop it in your mouth & relish the unique experience. It won't be too long before you start asking yourself the age-old question "Melody Itni Chocolaty Kyun Hai?”.” Cong Attacks Modi Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and several other Congress leaders also attacked Modi saying he continues his PR even when the economy is suffering. However, Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal hit back at Gandhi, accusing him of "hating India" and refusing to tolerate the "global respect" the country has garnered under Modi's leadership. Gandhi, who is on a visit to his constituency Raebareli and Amethi, said on X, "This isn't leadership, it's a gimmick." At a time farmers, labourers, traders and others in the country are all in tears, the prime minister is laughing and making reels while BJP folks are clapping along, the former Congress president said in his post in Hindi. "An economic storm is raging over our heads, and our prime minister is busy handing out candies in Italy!" he said. Congress chief Mallikarjun Kharge attacked Modi over issues of "rising" prices, unemployment, paper leaks, "dampening" investment and "sinking" Rupee, saying the prime minister continues his PR even as the economy is suffering. Shares turn sweet but the company was mistaken Shares of Parle Industries Ltd saw frenzied buying on Wednesday, surging five per cent to hit the upper circuit limit after Meloni posted the video. Investors wasted no time and flocked to the counter to buy the stock. Shares of the firm jumped to Rs 5.25 - the highest trading permissible limit for the day - on the BSE. On volume terms, 8.57 lakh shares of the firm were traded on the BSE during the day. But, there is a catch! Investors mistook Parle Industries for the maker of Melody toffees. Parle Products, the FMCG major, is the manufacturer of Melody toffees and is not listed on the stock exchanges. Parle Industries Ltd is a diversified commercial services provider, engaged in the business of infrastructure & real estate, and paper, waste paper and allied products. The history of swadeshi toffee is entwined with the country’s Independence and the company, House of Parle was founded in 1928 by Mohanlal Dayal Chauhan, a tailor from Pardi near Valsad, then part of the Bombay Province. As the country was flooded with imported sweets and confectionery, he decided to give it a ‘desi’ touch and flavour, and with a band of 12 workers, he launched the Parle products from a musty old warehouse near Vile Parle east station, when large parts areas of Vile Parle west were still marshes dotted with a few old bungalows and chawls. Later, he visited Germany to master the art of confectionery and returned with machinery worth Rs 60,000 to churn out simple sweets, toffees and locally flavoured Indian confections at affordable prices – willy-nilly challenging the imported British offerings. It was in 1983 that the chocolate Melody toffee. -WITH PTI

Indonesia's IMIP Airport: Illegal Operations or Oversight Failure?

The controversy highlights Indonesia’s core dilemma — attracting investment and industrial growth without surrendering control or weakening governance.


Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin
Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin

A privately run airport inside one of Indonesia’s largest nickel-processing hubs has ignited a national debate over sovereignty and oversight. It is alleged to have operated for six years without central supervision or the routine presence of customs, immigration or AirNav officials, raising urgent questions about what passed through that airspace — and under whose authority.


The private airport sits within the Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park (IMIP), a 4,000-acre complex in Morowali, Central Sulawesi. Backed by Chinese and Indonesian investment, IMIP is central to the global EV battery supply chain and a strategic pillar of Indonesia’s industrial policy.


The controversy has drawn political attention nationally and regionally. During a visit to Morowali last month, Defence Minister Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin questioned the airport’s status, warning that any facility operating without central authority undermines the state and that there cannot be a “second republic” within Indonesia. Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa has also said the government will verify whether the airport is properly licensed.


However, IMIP’s management rejects any wrongdoing, arguing that Indonesia’s Aviation Law No. 1/2009 allows special-purpose airports to support industrial operations with ministerial approval.


However, this is not the only such airport in Indonesia; similar special-status facilities exist elsewhere. The controversy stems from allegations that it operated regular international flights — a breach of the law, which bars such airports from handling international traffic or commercial passengers.


IMIP: Indonesia’s Nickel Powerhouse

IMIP is one of the world’s largest nickel-processing and stainless-steel complexes, located on the Central Sulawesi coast. It is central to Indonesia’s push to become a major hub for EV battery materials, with its nickel serving as a key input for battery cathodes.


Indonesia holds the world’s largest nickel reserves, and since banning raw ore exports in 2020, it has drawn a surge of foreign investment—especially from China—into processing and refining. IMIP is the flagship of this policy. Chinese firms, led by Tsingshan, have built processing lines at a scale and pace unmatched by Western companies. The complex now feeds both the stainless-steel and EV battery industries, making it vital to the global energy transition and a focal point of China–West cooperation and competition.


A Red Flag

Private airstrips are common in remote mining and plantation areas, but IMIP’s airport has raised deeper concerns for three structural reasons.


First, this was not a small strip used occasionally by executives; it reportedly handled regular traffic, including chartered worker flights. Second, the controversy centres on whether the airport had consistent on-site customs, immigration and aviation regulators. In such a strategic industrial zone, any sign of weak oversight quickly becomes a sovereignty issue. Third, IMIP is heavily Chinese-invested and Chinese-managed — effectively controlled by foreign entities.


The issue would likely have drawn far less attention had domestic firms been involved. But from an Indonesian perspective — shaped by history, labour disputes, environmental concerns and anxieties over China’s rise — such a situation carries weight. The idea of a Chinese-dominated enclave running an airport with minimal state visibility was bound to raise suspicion.

 

China’s Footprint

In many ways, IMIP embodies China’s industrial power. Chinese firms have supplied the financing, engineering, technology and management needed to process Indonesian ore at scale. This is the main reason Indonesia so quickly emerged as the world’s centre of nickel processing.


But such dominance also creates sensitivities. If Indonesia’s nickel sector grows too dependent on Chinese capital, it risks losing bargaining power. Rapid industrial expansion can also outpace local regulators’ capacity, fuelling concern that foreign companies may be carving out “special zones” where the state appears weaker.


China–West Rivalry?

The EV transition has turned nickel, cobalt and rare earths into geopolitical tools. Competition over nickel is real but far from equal: China dominates Indonesia’s processing capacity by a wide margin.


China’s early investment in IMIP created a structural advantage. Western firms, constrained by stricter environmental rules and slower corporate processes, never built smelters at a comparable speed. As a result, Indonesia’s most strategic mineral zone is shaped overwhelmingly by Chinese corporate logic. Western companies and governments have only recently begun to take Indonesian nickel seriously. What is unfolding is not an outright battle but a subtler contest for long-term control of supply chains.

 

Indonesia’s Future Dilemma

A single airport does not threaten Indonesia’s sovereignty, but the IMIP case does raise doubts about whether some industrial enclaves are growing faster than the state can regulate. The real risk is not secession but governance erosion. The episode reflects Indonesia’s core tension: seeking foreign investment without foreign dominance, rapid industrialisation without regulatory decay, and leadership in the nickel and battery sector without weakening sovereignty. These balances are difficult for any investment-dependent country, and IMIP’s airport has simply made them more visible.


(The writer is a foreign affairs expert. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page