top of page

By:

Abhijit Mulye

21 August 2024 at 4:59:11 pm

Fadnavis reins in Sena’s Marathi push

AI generated image Mumbai: The ruling Mahayuti coalition in Maharashtra is witnessing a delicate political balancing act, with Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis increasingly overriding key decisions of alliance partners, particularly the Shiv Sena, while simultaneously attempting to placate them on other fronts. The tension within the alliance came to the fore on Thursday when Fadnavis stepped in to dilute a controversial mandate enforced by Shiv Sena Transport Minister Pratap Sarnaik, which...

Fadnavis reins in Sena’s Marathi push

AI generated image Mumbai: The ruling Mahayuti coalition in Maharashtra is witnessing a delicate political balancing act, with Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis increasingly overriding key decisions of alliance partners, particularly the Shiv Sena, while simultaneously attempting to placate them on other fronts. The tension within the alliance came to the fore on Thursday when Fadnavis stepped in to dilute a controversial mandate enforced by Shiv Sena Transport Minister Pratap Sarnaik, which required auto-rickshaw and taxi drivers in Mumbai to possess basic Marathi language proficiency. The Transport Department’s enforcement drive, which threatened non-Marathi-speaking drivers with suspension or cancellation of their licences, sparked outrage among North Indian drivers who form a sizeable section of the public transport workforce in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR). Protests brought parts of Mumbai, including Kandivali and Malad, to a standstill. Recognising the potential electoral fallout, Fadnavis intervened, saying drivers need not be “experts” in Marathi. He also extended the grace period for drivers to acquire a working knowledge of the language to one year, effectively diluting Sarnaik’s hardline stance. Fadnavis announced the decision after a delegation of transport operators met him. The episode highlights the conflicting political compulsions of the Mahayuti partners. Eknath Shinde’s Shiv Sena is keen to pursue a pro-Marathi, “sons of the soil” agenda to consolidate its traditional voter base and counter the rival Shiv Sena (UBT) faction led by Uddhav Thackeray. The BJP, however, relies heavily on North Indian and migrant voters in the MMR, particularly as crucial civic and state elections approach. Any aggressive regional policy that alienates this constituency could have electoral consequences for the party. The Marathi language issue is not an isolated instance of Fadnavis stepping in to override decisions associated with the Shiv Sena. It fits into a broader pattern of the chief minister’s administration reviewing or reversing several initiatives of the previous government headed by Shinde. In April 2026, the BJP-led Environment Department, headed by Minister Pankaja Munde, scrapped 14 lake conservation projects, 11 of which had been cleared during Shinde’s tenure, and ordered recovery of more than Rs 73 crore. The Fadnavis government has also modified several initiatives introduced by the previous regime. In January 2025, it altered Shinde’s three-course school meal plan, placing the responsibility on local school management committees to raise funds for sweet dishes. In April 2025, the government scrapped the ‘One State, One Uniform’ policy for schools. A Rs 3,200-crore tender for mechanised housekeeping services at government hospitals, issued under the Shinde government, was also stayed. Yet, Fadnavis remains conscious of the need to preserve the fragile alliance. To manage growing resentment within the Sena, he has adopted what can be described as a ‘blow hot, blow cold’ approach — overriding decisions when they clash with the BJP’s broader political interests while offering political concessions on other fronts. One such move was the recent appointment of Shiv Sena leader Bharat Gogawale as Guardian Minister of the politically important Raigad district, ending a 19-month-long tussle over the post. At the same time, the Mahayuti government recently reduced the powers exercised by Guardian Ministers over District Planning Committee (DPC) funds, directing that 70 per cent of the funds be allocated directly to local MLAs. The move is aimed at reducing the concentration of financial powers with individual ministers. As the Mahayuti navigates these competing interests, Fadnavis has also instructed alliance partners to resolve disputes internally and avoid public sparring. However, the latest confrontation over the Marathi language requirement underscores the limits of that arrangement. While Fadnavis continues to use his authority to protect the BJP’s broader electoral interests, the Shiv Sena remains under pressure to assert its regional identity and distinguish itself from the Thackeray faction. With elections approaching, balancing these competing political priorities is likely to remain one of the biggest challenges for the Mahayuti government.

Marathi Pride and the Taxi Debate

A proposed rule for taxi drivers is turning into a wider test of Marathi identity and the political risks of enforcing linguistic pride.

Maharashtra marked the 66th year of its foundation yesterday. As with every other May 1 celebration that has taken place in six decades, this year, too, Maharashtra Day was celebrated not just with mere pageantry, but with a memory of fire. The state’s birth in 1960, wrested from the old Bombay State after a turbulent Samyukta Maharashtra Movement, still lingers in its political and cultural DNA. That the day coincides with International Labour Day only deepens its meaning, tying the assertion of identity to the labour that built one of India’s most formidable states.


Marathi Mandatory

But this year, along with celebrations, an important and sensitive debate has taken centre stage — whether Marathi should be compulsory for auto and taxi drivers. In the last few weeks, Maharashtra found itself close to a serious policy and political discussion. Transport Minister Pratap Sarnaik proposed that all auto and taxi drivers must be able to speak basic Marathi. Initially, there were strong signals that from May 1, 2026, drivers who failed to comply could even risk losing their licences. This created both excitement and fear. Many Marathi-speaking citizens welcomed the move, seeing it as a step towards preserving their language. At the same time, thousands of drivers, especially those from outside Maharashtra, felt uncertain about their future. As Marathi speakers, many of us feel proud of our language. We often admire how people in states like West Bengal or in South India strongly use their own language in daily life. But when we look at ourselves, a different picture appears.


In everyday situations, whether it is speaking to a taxi driver or buying vegetables, we quickly switch to Hindi. Even in groups of Marathi people, if one person does not understand Marathi, everyone changes their language instead of helping that person learn. So, the question is simple: if we ourselves do not use Marathi regularly, can we expect others to learn it? The issue soon moved beyond language and became political.


Parties like the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena, led by Raj Thackeray, supported the idea strongly, saying Marathi must be respected in Maharashtra. On the other hand, leaders like Sanjay Nirupam and labour representatives questioned the decision. They argued that forcing language rules could hurt workers, especially those who have come from states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar to earn a living. Many of these drivers have been working for years without any major communication problems.


Political Complexity

Alongside the public debate, a sharper political subtext is hard to ignore. Questions are already swirling over whether Pratap Sarnaik’s decision followed full consultation with Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis or whether it was a more calculated gambit. To some, the move looks less like policy and more like positioning: a bid to signal linguistic assertiveness and consolidate Marathi sentiment.


Yet such manoeuvres carry risk. Should the policy provoke unrest - as in among drivers or a wider public backlash, then the political costs may not rest with its architect alone, but with the Chief Minister, who ultimately bears the burden of governance.


Another perspective suggests that even if the leadership was aware, there may have been hesitation in fully supporting such a strict rule as the ruling BJP has a strong base in the Hindi belt and an important state like Maharashtra could not safeguard their own people – which could be double sword fight for the CM.


In that case, the issue could be used politically to create an impression that some leaders are not fully supportive of Marathi identity. In simple terms, whichever way the situation unfolds, the political pressure seems to circle back to the top leadership — especially Devendra Fadnavis — making this not just a social issue but a strategic political challenge. As tensions increased, the government appeared to take a balanced approach.


The strict deadline of May 1 was relaxed, and more time was given until August 15 for drivers to learn basic Marathi. At the same time, new developments —including discussions around other political and local issues — have also come into focus, indirectly shifting attention and creating pressure on key decision-makers.


This shows how quickly public issues in politics can change direction. While the idea of promoting Marathi is widely supported, many people are asking an important question — is this the right time and the right way? With the new deadline still months away, the situation may change further. There could be new protests, policy changes, or even completely different discussions taking over the public space. Marathi is the soul of Maharashtra and deserves respect and promotion. But Maharashtra is also a state that welcomes people from all over India. These people contribute to the economy and daily life of cities like Mumbai.


The solution may not lie in strict rules, but in encouragement and support. Language learning can be made simple and friendly. Citizens can also take responsibility by using Marathi more often and helping others learn. Maharashtra Day is a time to celebrate unity, culture, and progress.


The current debate reminds us that growth comes with challenges. Language should bring people together, not push them apart. A thoughtful and balanced approach can ensure that Marathi continues to grow while also protecting the livelihoods of thousands of hardworking people. As the situation develops in the coming months, one thing is clear — this is not just about language. It is about identity, politics, and the future direction of Maharashtra. And as many would say in simple words — “Aap samajh rahe ho na?”


(The writer is a political observer. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page