top of page

By:

Quaid Najmi

4 January 2025 at 8:56:24 pm

‘Save Sharia’ campaign feeds Hindutva politics

Mumbai: Prominent Muslims and others have slammed the All India Muslim Personal Law Board’s ‘Save India, Save Sharia’ nationwide campaign, alleging that it could deepen polarization while willy-nilly supporting the very forces the AIMPLB claims to oppose. Launched on Sep. 17 – coinciding with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 76th birthday – the AIMPLB’s 3-month-long campaign is aimed at mobilizing public opinion around protecting the Constitutional rights, preserving the Muslim Personal Law...

‘Save Sharia’ campaign feeds Hindutva politics

Mumbai: Prominent Muslims and others have slammed the All India Muslim Personal Law Board’s ‘Save India, Save Sharia’ nationwide campaign, alleging that it could deepen polarization while willy-nilly supporting the very forces the AIMPLB claims to oppose. Launched on Sep. 17 – coinciding with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 76th birthday – the AIMPLB’s 3-month-long campaign is aimed at mobilizing public opinion around protecting the Constitutional rights, preserving the Muslim Personal Law within the framework of safeguarding India’s pluralistic and democratic character. The AIMPLB leaders said they are soliciting support of people, intellectuals, activists, social and religious organisations who value justice, democracy, peace and the Constitution, to strengthen constitutional supremacy, the rule of law, justice and equality, religious freedom, social harmony and national unity. Around 100 progressive Muslim and non-Muslim intellectuals, activists, organisations and supporters have warned that what the AIMPLB presents as a defence of constitutional rights, religious freedom and Muslim identity "could deepen divisions, and may provide political ammunition to right-wing forces". The progressive have accused AIMPLB of selectively invoking Art. 25-30 of the Constitution related to Religious Freedom, while ignoring that these rights are explicitly subject to public order, morality, and health. Moreover, they conveniently bypass Articles 14 and 15, which guarantee equality before the law and prohibit sex or religion-based discrimination. “Following the 2024 Lok Sabha elections where civil society and opposition parties rallied under 'Save the Constitution', the AIMPLB's campaign inadvertently gave the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Sangh Parivar a platform to posture as defenders of constitutional norms. Ahead of crucial state assembly elections, this campaign reinforces false narratives and fuels propaganda that Indian Muslims reject the law of the land,” said the intellectuals. They pointed out how the so-called ‘God-given Shariat Law’ in India is nothing but man-made personal laws and ‘male interpreted patriarchal interpretations’, defended by the AIMPLB. In its September 2016 Supreme Court affidavit in the Triple Talaq case (Sayara Bano v/s. Union of India), the AIMPLB’s affidavit claimed divorce rights belong primarily to husbands because men allegedly possess ‘greater power of decision-making’ and ‘control emotions’. It even argued that without a quick separation option, a husband ‘may resort to illegal, criminal ways of murdering or burning her alive’ - a disturbing rationalization of domestic violence. Claiming these laws are divine, the AIMPLB admitted that “India is a patriarchal society, and therefore personal laws of all communities are aligned with the patriarchal notion...” The progressives countered that Muslim-majority nations globally including Pakistan, Bangladesh, Tunisia and Morocco have codified and reformed personal laws to protect women's rights. “Millions of Muslims live in secular democratic nations with uniform family codes without putting ‘Islam in danger’. The Muslim community’s current legal predicament in India is the direct result of the AIMPLB and conservative leaders failing to proactively reform and codify Muslim Personal Law,” said the progressives sharply. They said that genuine family law reform must guarantee Muslim women equal rights regarding minimum marriage age, abolition of polygamy, mutual divorce, equal inheritance, child custody, adoption, and a ban on female genital mutilation and halala. While secular political parties rarely support the rights of Muslim women, the BJP and the Hindu Right wing do so with an obvious motive: ‘communal polarization’, said the progressives. “The sangh parivar sheds crocodile tears for Muslim women while ignoring relentless hate speech (Love Jihad, Land Jihad…) and hate crimes like mob lynching, bulldozing homes, demolishing mosques or economic boycotts, with chants of ‘Jai Shri Ram’ to intimidate and strike fear. This accompanies state actions targeting Muslims: Waqf Amendment Act, draconian anti-conversion laws, and a weaponised SIR (Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls) to disenfranchise vast sections of the electorate,” they averred. The progressives have sought the active involvement of all enlightened forces, civil society organisations and secular political parties to ensure that the demand for a gender-just, religion-neutral Uniform Civil Code is rooted in equality and human rights, rather than weaponized for communal division. Among the signatories to the appeal are: Naseeruddin Shah, Amol Palekar, Zeenat Shaukat Ali, Anand Patwardhan, Sultan Shaheen, Teesta Setalvad, Ram Puniyani, Tushar Gandhi, Mallika Sarabhai, Ratna Pathak, Feroze Mithiborwala, Anita Cheria, Zakia Soman, Jyothi Yedulla, Noorjehan S. Niaz, Madhu Bhaduri, et al.

‘Stampede, no fault of Arrangements’

Jan 30, 2025
2 min read

Updated: Jan 31, 2025

A Mumbaikar businessman narrates the scene in Prayagraj


 Pramod Khadse

Mumbai: While the Uttar Pradesh government is facing flak over the deaths of 30 devotees in Maha Kumbh, a devotee told ‘The Perfect Voice’ that the arrangements were very well organised, and the stampede occurred mainly due to indiscipline of the devotees.


Mumbai-based businessman Pramod Khadse who managed to reach the most sought after destination Sangam nose on the afternoon of Thursday, January 31 recalled his experience. “The arrangements are excellent. Crores of people have visited this spot. The security is perfect. It is very very sad that so many people died.”


Khadse said, “The pilgrims had arrived the spot early morning, and all of them had fallen asleep in the restricted area near the barricades. Naturally, the security teams tried to vacate that area, and in the process the chaos happened because the pilgrims were sleeping and were very drowsy.”


He pointed out that although the arrangements are excellent, the crowd is so huge that traffic jam has made the process miserable. “It is difficult to blame anyone. The number of pilgrims is so much and I vouch for the fact that the arrangements are flawless but traffic jams are inevitable due to the large number of crowd. I found it nearly important to reach the Sangam nose.”


“My vehicle was stopped 14 km from the actual site. Later, I had to walk for 22 km. Everyone is abandoning their vehicles after a point and walking to Sangam nose. I finally reached and took the holy dip twice.”


The Sangam Nose at the confluence of the Ganga, Yamuna, and the Saraswati rivers, attracts millions of devotees during the Kumbh Mela. Close to 15 crore devotees have visited the spot this year. The devotees believe that taking a dip in the Sangam washes away sins and frees people from the cycle of birth and rebirth.


At least 30 pilgrims were killed, dozens injured and many separated from their families as a humungous group of devotees tried to break through barriers to reach the nose at the Triveni Sangam.


Travel becomes expensive

After the mishap on Wednesday a few pilgrims pointed out that the travel has become a big challenge because the prices have shot up exponentially. Devotees planning a trip to Prayagraj in February are worried because airfare to Varanasi and Prayagraj has shot up as high as Rs 20-25,000, which otherwise usually is Rs 4-5,000.


Mumbai based Chartered accountant Manoj Tiwari who will has planned to travel to the Sangam Nose in February said, “I still want to go, especially with the historical significance and how rare this event is. It must feel like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. The mishap is certainly concerning, but sometimes such incidents are unavoidable in big events. It’s tough to say who’s at fault without more info, but safety measures might need to be heightened in situations like this.”


He added, “Travel being expensive is an issue right now. It’s understandable with train services being unpredictable and flights being nearly impossible to get, the options are limited. Private vehicles seem like the only feasible way to go, though that can come with its own set of problems—like high costs and long travel time.”

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page