top of page

By:

Quaid Najmi

4 January 2025 at 3:26:24 pm

Shinde ‘feasts’ on Thackeray’s party

AI generated image Mumbai: The Shiv Sena (UBT)’s worst fears proved true on Thursday when six suspected ‘turncoat’ MPs failed to attend its crucial parliamentary party meeting in New Delhi – signaling another ‘split’ in four years – and posing a serious challenge to ex-Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray’s leadership and credibility. The crucial parliamentary party meeting saw only three (out of total 9) Lok Sabha MPs – Arvind Sawant (Mumbai South), Anil Desai (Mumbai South-Central) and...

Shinde ‘feasts’ on Thackeray’s party

AI generated image Mumbai: The Shiv Sena (UBT)’s worst fears proved true on Thursday when six suspected ‘turncoat’ MPs failed to attend its crucial parliamentary party meeting in New Delhi – signaling another ‘split’ in four years – and posing a serious challenge to ex-Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray’s leadership and credibility. The crucial parliamentary party meeting saw only three (out of total 9) Lok Sabha MPs – Arvind Sawant (Mumbai South), Anil Desai (Mumbai South-Central) and Rajabhau Waje (Nashik) – in attendance as per a whip issued two days ago, when the so-called ‘Operation Tiger’ was in advanced stages. At the tense meeting, with their eyes trained on the doors, they waited for over an hour for their six LS colleagues - Sanjay Dina Patil (Mumbai North East), Nagesh Patil Ashtikar (Hingoli), Sanjay Jadhav (Parbhani), Omprakash Nimbalkar (Dharashiv), Sanjay Deshmukh (Yavatmal-Washim) and Bhausaheb Wakchaure (Shirdi) – who never turned up. Emerging from the meeting the ruffled trio of Raut, Sawant and Desai confronted the huge crowd of media-persons and announced what was already public knowledge – that the SS (UBT) was breaking again. A tense Sawant somehow managed to smile and said that since the 6 MPs have defied the party whip, they would face the appropriate consequences. “We have followed the procedures and sent them individual show-cause notices, seeking their replies within a week,” he said. Raut said that if they fail to reply to the show-cause notices, then the party will initiate the necessary proceedings – in the Parliament, the courts and the streets. Operation Tudva In a raging mood, Raut warned that the SS (UBT) workers will ‘teach’ all the six MPs a lesson and now the party had launched a counter ‘Operation Tudva’ – akin to a similar initiative implemented successfully by the (undivided) NCP in 2019. “They are unscrupulous, unprincipled traitors. We have been told that they have taken huge sums of money to break away from our party. They took Rs 15-cr. to board the chartered aircraft two days ago, and yesterday again took Rs 10-cr to go to an undisclosed destination in Rajasthan,” claimed Raut, his outburst splattered with expletives for the second day. He reiterated his demand that “if all the six MPs first resign from their seats and contest elections afresh, we shall not label them as traitors”, even as Nationalist Congress Party (SP) MLA Rohit Pawar alleged that each MP reportedly stood to make Rs 85-cr, plus more through other means. Threatening MPs Angry Shiv Sainiks burnt effigies of all the MPs in their respective constituencies and threatened of physical attacks or their properties, prompting the state government to accord them Y-Plus category security as per a wireless directives issued by the State Commissioner of Intelligence Shirish Jain today. Indicating deep fissures, the absence of the six MPs pointed to the likelihood of them officially preparing to align with the Shiv Sena led by Deputy CM Eknath Shinde marking success of the ‘Operation Tiger’. Yesterday, the rebels had called on Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla and submitted a letter seeking to be recognized as a separate parliamentary group. The SS (UBT) also met the Speaker yesterday to submit a counter-letter and urged him to refrain from according any recognition to the breakaway group, and stick to the laws and Constitutional norms. However, if the Speaker accepts the rebels’ plea, it could formalize the impending ‘split’ and prove a huge setback for the SS (UBT). Eknath Shinde gets the “lion’s share” of SS (UBT) Prowling stealthily and effectively Shiv Sena President and Deputy CM Eknath Shinde ostensibly masterminded the ‘Operation Tiger’ and took away the lion’s share of 6 (out of 9) MPs from his bete-noire, ex-CM Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena (UBT) – for the second time in 4 years with lot of symbolism attached to the political man-hunt. Though party sources remained tight-lipped, it is learnt that Shinde’s ace team of political and legal advisors have gone through all the nitty-gritties, all the possibilities, the fallout in Parliament, the courts and the streets, before giving the green signal to strike at Thackeray’s party. On the next course, a party leader said that “only Shinde-ji has the authority” to decide and speak on this”, and he may well have some new aces up his trademark white-shirt sleeves in the coming days.

Studying Hinduism Through an Indian Lens

Hindu Studies Centres seek to examine the tradition through indigenous knowledge systems rather than Western academic frameworks.

AI generated image
AI generated image

In many universities across the world, religion-based philosophy is taught with a critical and analytical approach. Prestigious Ivy League institutions like Harvard University have dedicated schools such as the Harvard Divinity School, where Hindu religion and philosophy are taught—often by foreign scholars. Similarly, many universities host Centres for Religious Studies or South Asian Studies, where Hinduism and its philosophical traditions are studied. The Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies is one such institution fully devoted to Hindu studies, offering numerous online courses to Indian, international, and diaspora students. Many Hindu industrialists contribute financially to such centres. However, it is important to note that these institutions largely follow Western research methodologies.


This raises an important question: why should there not be institutions, centres, or university departments in India that study Hinduism based on Indian research methodologies and knowledge systems? Indian universities have long-established departments for Islamic Studies, Buddhist Studies, and Jainology. However, similar efforts for Hindu studies have either not been made or have been discouraged. A compromise often adopted is to name such departments “Indian Studies” instead of explicitly using the term "Hindu".


It is said that a few years ago, a university declined a donation for establishing a Hindu Studies centre simply because the name “Hindu” was not acceptable. This reflects certain ideological tendencies that have existed in higher education.


Against this backdrop, through the efforts of the vice-chancellor and members of the management council of the University of Mumbai, a Hindu philosophy study centre was established in February 2022, later renamed the Hindu Studies Centre. The challenge then was to design curricula free from Western dominance and rooted in Indian knowledge systems and indigenous research methodologies.


In the same year, the University Grants Commission proposed that universities across India adopt a standardised curriculum for Hindu studies centres. Consequently, the Hindu Studies Centre at the University of Mumbai launched an M.A. programme in Hindu Studies. Additionally, programmes such as an M.A. in Keertan Shastra (Marathi tradition), a Postgraduate Diploma in Temple Management, and three online courses based on the Bhagavad Gita were introduced.


The M.A. in Hindu Studies includes subjects such as Dharma, Purusharthas, Rin (debts), epistemology (Pramana-Mimamsa), Vedas, Upanishads, Ramayana, Mahabharata, Bhagavad Gita, Bhakti traditions, Sanskrit, rebirth, Karma theory, and the six classical systems of philosophy (Shad Darshanas). Temple management studies include infrastructure, environmental sustainability, disaster management, welfare schemes, and crowd management.


Recent films have portrayed that Hindus often have very limited knowledge of their own religion. When such uninformed youth step onto the global stage, they may become confused, misled, or influenced by misinformation. Therefore, initiatives like Hindu Studies Centres must be widely embraced by the Hindu community.


These centres do not focus on rituals or religious practices but instead aim to develop a perspective on society, encourage harmonious social engagement, prevent intellectual manipulation, promote life values, and advocate an eco-friendly way of living. If we fail to support such initiatives, then the effort to build a scholarly, Indian, knowledge-based understanding of Hinduism will go in vain—and that would be truly unfortunate.


(The writer is a professor at Mumbai University. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page