top of page

By:

Quaid Najmi

4 January 2025 at 3:26:24 pm

Congress’ solo path for ‘ideological survival’

Mumbai: The Congress party’s decision to contest the forthcoming BrihanMumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) elections independently is being viewed as an attempt to reclaim its ideological space among the public and restore credibility within its cadre, senior leaders indicated. The announcement - made by AICC General Secretary Ramesh Chennithala alongside state president Harshwardhan Sapkal and Mumbai Congress chief Varsha Gaikwad - did not trigger a backlash from the Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi...

Congress’ solo path for ‘ideological survival’

Mumbai: The Congress party’s decision to contest the forthcoming BrihanMumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) elections independently is being viewed as an attempt to reclaim its ideological space among the public and restore credibility within its cadre, senior leaders indicated. The announcement - made by AICC General Secretary Ramesh Chennithala alongside state president Harshwardhan Sapkal and Mumbai Congress chief Varsha Gaikwad - did not trigger a backlash from the Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA) partners, the Nationalist Congress Party (SP) and Shiv Sena (UBT). According to Congress insiders, the move is the outcome of more than a year of intense internal consultations following the party’ dismal performance in the 2024 Assembly elections, belying huge expectations. A broad consensus reportedly emerged that the party should chart a “lone-wolf” course to safeguard the core ideals of Congress, turning140-years-old, next month. State and Mumbai-level Congress leaders, speaking off the record, said that although the party gained momentum in the 2019 Assembly and 2024 Lok Sabha elections, it was frequently constrained by alliance compulsions. Several MVA partners, they claimed, remained unyielding on larger ideological and political issues. “The Congress had to compromise repeatedly and soften its position, but endured it as part of ‘alliance dharma’. Others did not reciprocate in the same spirit. They made unilateral announcements and declared candidates or policies without consensus,” a senior state leader remarked. Avoid liabilities He added that some alliance-backed candidates later proved to be liabilities. Many either lost narrowly or, even after winning with the support of Congress workers, defected to Mahayuti constituents - the Bharatiya Janata Party, Shiv Sena, or the Nationalist Congress Party. “More than five dozen such desertions have taken place so far, which is unethical, backstabbing the voters and a waste of all our efforts,” he rued. A Mumbai office-bearer elaborated that in certain constituencies, Congress workers effectively propelled weak allied candidates through the campaign. “Our assessment is that post-split, some partners have alienated their grassroots base, especially in the mofussil regions. They increasingly rely on Congress workers. This is causing disillusionment among our cadre, who see deserving leaders being sidelined and organisational growth stagnating,” he said. Chennithala’s declaration on Saturday was unambiguous: “We will contest all 227 seats independently in the BMC polls. This is the demand of our leaders and workers - to go alone in the civic elections.” Gaikwad added that the Congress is a “cultured and respectable party” that cannot ally with just anyone—a subtle reference to the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), which had earlier targeted North Indians and other communities and is now bidding for an electoral arrangement with the SS(UBT). Both state and city leaders reiterated that barring the BMC elections - where the Congress will take the ‘ekla chalo’ route - the MVA alliance remains intact. This is despite the sharp criticism recently levelled at the Congress by senior SS(UBT) leader Ambadas Danve following the Bihar results. “We are confident that secular-minded voters will support the Congress' fight against the BJP-RSS in local body elections. We welcome backing from like-minded parties and hope to finalize understandings with some soon,” a state functionary hinted. Meanwhile, Chennithala’s firm stance has triggered speculation in political circles about whether the Congress’ informal ‘black-sheep' policy vis-a-vis certain parties will extend beyond the BMC polls.

Tickets for Sale

The ticket distribution for the upcoming 2025 Bihar Assembly elections reveals a democracy in decay, where caste, cash and chaos have replaced merit and public service.

ree

The violence and chaos surrounding ticket distribution for the 2025 Bihar Assembly elections are not new. They are merely the latest act in a decades-long political drama. Today, ticket allocation is no longer a matter of political merit or ideological conviction. It has become a theatre of caste, factionalism, money and opportunism. What once reflected democratic deliberation has degenerated into a showcase of influence, nepotism and transactional politics.


In the 1950s and 60s, when Congress dominated Bihar, caste dynamics and local power groups existed, but political disputes rarely turned violent. Politics, even modestly, retained civility; leaders resolved differences without muscle or street brawls. That moral order disintegrated in the 1990s, when post-Mandal politics under Lalu Prasad Yadav redefined the state’s political grammar through caste pride and social mobilisation. What began as a movement for justice gradually became a contest of caste egos. Yadavs, Kurmis, Dalits and sections of Muslims competed fiercely for party tickets. Violence among RJD and Janata Dal supporters became commonplace. Public meetings, once platforms for debate, turned into displays of strength, birthing entitlement and rebellion whenever coveted tickets were denied.


The coalition years from 2000 to 2010 made the landscape murkier. Seat-sharing negotiations tested alliances, while disgruntled local leaders often rebelled as independents, weakening parties from within. Every election season, ticket announcements sparked uproar: chairs flew, tempers flared, sometimes fists too. Congress headquarters in Patna’s Sadaqat Ashram became a recurring scene of chaos; BJP and RJD offices faced similar protests. By 2020, a new toxin had entered Bihar’s political bloodstream: money. Ticket distribution became less about public service and more about financial transactions. Parachuted candidates, who are outsiders with wealth or influence, began muscling in, leaving loyal grassroots workers alienated.


The run-up to the 2025 election exposes the system’s rot. A scuffle at Patna airport involving Congress leaders Krishna Allavaru and state president Rajesh Ram, amid allegations of ticket-selling, symbolises the moral freefall. BJP faces internal protests after dropping senior legislators. In the JD(U), MLA Gopal Mandal staged a sit-in in a VIP zone of the state government area, while MP Ajay Mandal offered to resign. RJD leaders confront rebellion over the Muslim-Yadav equation, with protests reaching Tejashwi Yadav’s doorstep. This is emblematic of a democracy on life support.


Deep fractures

Political analysts agree that Bihar’s ticket allocation has drifted far from merit, representation and public service. Money, donations and family lineage now outweigh competence and credibility. Hardworking cadres are sidelined in favour of rich newcomers or the well-connected elite. The result is deep fractures within parties and a dangerous breed of internal dissent that erodes both discipline and public faith. Senior politicians lobbying for their children or even film celebrities, while bureaucrats gain direct entry into electoral politics, reveal not modernisation but moral decay.


The growing influence of national parties, who often import candidates into Bihar from outside the state, has further complicated local politics. Such candidates, lacking grassroots connections, rely on money and muscle to secure support, undermining the very democratic process they claim to serve. Meanwhile, regional strongmen exploit the same vacuum to consolidate personal power, turning party offices into arenas of intimidation rather than deliberation.


The increasing violence, slogan-shouting and chair-throwing are not merely internal matters; they are warnings about the erosion of democratic values. When parties abandon internal democracy, they cannot nurture democracy outside. When the race for tickets is fought with fists, cash and caste, what message does that send to a young democracy already disillusioned by corruption and cronyism?


Dangerous paradox

Bihar’s politics today mirrors the most dangerous paradox of Indian democracy: elections without ethics. If every seat is for sale and every rebellion is an ego battle, politics ceases to be public service and becomes private enterprise. The people of Bihar, once vibrant participants in grassroots politics, now watch from the sidelines, disenchanted and disconnected.


There is a way out, but it demands courage. Parties must reinvent ticket distribution through transparency, accountability and respect for grassroots workers. Candidates should be chosen not for their capacity to fund campaigns but for credibility among the people. Those that open the windows of internal democracy might rediscover public trust.


Bihar’s history of electoral strife from Congress-era civility to coalition-era chaos and the present age of cash and caste tells a consistent story of politics forgetting its ethical foundation. Such cases have invariably led to violence and cynicism filling the vacuum. The 2025 poll ticket distribution saga is not merely a local issue but a mirror of the crises eating at Indian democracy. Unless Bihar’s political class rebuilds honesty, fairness and equality within its own walls, democracy will continue to be mocked in the marketplace of power.


Without reform, Bihar risks normalising transactional politics, where elections become a spectacle of wealth and influence rather than a forum for citizen choice. The state’s political malaise offers a cautionary tale for India at large, that democracy cannot survive if the machinery of parties themselves is corrupt.

Comments


bottom of page