top of page

By:

Abhijit Mulye

21 August 2024 at 4:59:11 pm

MLC polls expose cracks in Mahayuti, MVA

AI Generated Image Mumbai: The upcoming Maharashtra Legislative Council (MLC) elections for the graduate and teacher constituencies have laid bare the deep-seated fissures within both the ruling Mahayuti and the opposition Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) alliances. In a significant development that could have far-reaching political implications, multiple rebel candidates, including prominent figures with strong party affiliations, have defied alliance dictates to file their nominations as...

MLC polls expose cracks in Mahayuti, MVA

AI Generated Image Mumbai: The upcoming Maharashtra Legislative Council (MLC) elections for the graduate and teacher constituencies have laid bare the deep-seated fissures within both the ruling Mahayuti and the opposition Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) alliances. In a significant development that could have far-reaching political implications, multiple rebel candidates, including prominent figures with strong party affiliations, have defied alliance dictates to file their nominations as independents, setting the stage for high-stakes, multi-cornered contests. Mahayuti Turmoil The Mahayuti alliance, comprising the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena, and the Ajit Pawar-led Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), is grappling with rebellion on multiple fronts. In the critical Nagpur Graduates constituency, a traditional BJP stronghold, former BJP MLC and Nagpur Mayor Anil Sole has thrown a spanner in the works by filing his nomination as an independent candidate. This move directly challenges the official BJP candidate, Sudhakar Kohale. While the BJP leadership, including state president Ravindra Chavan, has attempted to downplay the situation, asserting that Sole has been "pacified," the former MLC's actions tell a different story. Sole's decision to contest independently is particularly significant given his long-standing association with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and his previous stint as a BJP MLC from the very same constituency. The situation is equally complicated in the Amravati Teachers constituency. The Shiv Sena (Shinde faction) has officially fielded Kiran Sarnaik. However, adding to the confusion, Sangita Shinde, sister of BJP MP Anil Bonde, has also entered the fray, potentially splitting the Mahayuti vote. The opposition MVA is also facing its share of internal discord here. While the Congress has nominated Aditi Pohre, daughter of former minister Harshvardhan Deshmukh, the Shiv Sena (UBT) has fielded Dattatray Lahane. The presence of numerous candidates representing various teachers' organizations further complicates the electoral arithmetic in this constituency. Opposition Rebellion The Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar Graduates constituency has witnessed another surprise development. While the NCP's sitting MLC, Satish Chavan, was widely considered the frontrunner, the BJP's M.K. Deshmukh has unexpectedly filed his nomination as a rebel candidate, catching the Mahayuti leadership completely off guard. The MVA, too, is facing rebellion in this constituency. Although the seat was officially allocated to the NCP (Sharad Pawar faction), Shiv Sena (UBT)'s Dilip Ghuge has also filed his nomination, causing significant heartburn within the opposition alliance. The Pune constituencies present a microcosm of the larger alliance troubles. In the Pune Graduates constituency, the BJP has fielded Dr. Smita Jadhav, the daughter-in-law of Pratap Singh Jadhav, owner of the 'Pudhari' news group and niece of Congress leader Satej Patil. Adding intrigue to this contest is the fact that she is contesting against Harshada Deshmukh-Jadhav, the official candidate of the NCP (Sharad Pawar faction). However, the real drama is unfolding in the Pune Teachers constituency. The BJP's official candidate, Koustubh Gawde, is facing a formidable challenge from Mangesh Chiwate, a close confidant of Chief Minister Eknath Shinde. Chiwate, a former journalist who handled the CM's medical aid cell while Shinde was the CM, has claimed that his party leadership has provided him with the crucial 'AB' form, signaling official backing. Commenting on the chaotic situation, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis acknowledged that seat-sharing talks remained inconclusive in some areas but expressed hope that the alliance partners would eventually reach an agreement. The true picture of the electoral battlefield will only emerge after Friday, October 9th, the last date for the withdrawal of nominations. Until then, both alliances will be working overtime to contain the rebellions and present a united front, but the deep cracks exposed by these developments suggest that the upcoming MLC elections will be fiercely contested and highly unpredictable.

From Balance Sheets to Nation-Building

Sep 15
3 min read

The balance sheet of a government belongs, in a broader sense, to the citizens.

In India’s rapidly evolving economic landscape, the role of a Chartered Accountant is no longer confined to balance sheets, audits and taxation. Increasingly, the profession is finding relevance in public policy, governance and political leadership. The journey of Chartered Accountants such as Piyush Goyal demonstrates how financial expertise can influence decisions far beyond the corporate world.


Piyush Goyal provides a compelling example of the CA-politics connection. An All-India second-rank Chartered Accountant, Goyal entered public life and went on to handle some of the country’s most important economic portfolios. His responsibilities have included finance, railways, power, coal and commerce & industry. He has also served as the BJP’s National Treasurer.


From a CA’s perspective, this journey is significant because governance is, to a large extent, about managing scarce resources. Every government has limited revenue but virtually unlimited demands. Decisions relating to taxation, infrastructure, subsidies, public expenditure and borrowing require not only political judgement but also financial discipline.


Consider Goyal’s tenure in the power sector. His official profile highlights initiatives such as Ujwal DISCOM Assurance Yojana (UDAY), the expansion of renewable energy, electrification and the UJALA (Unnat Jyoti by Affordable LEDs for All) programme. These are not merely political announcements; they involve financial planning, resource allocation, implementation and evaluation.


This is where the CA mindset becomes relevant to politics. A Chartered Accountant is trained to question assumptions, examine evidence, identify financial risks and assess whether resources are being used efficiently. When these skills are applied to public policy, the questions become larger: Is the policy financially sustainable? What is its impact on government finances? What are the long-term liabilities? Is public expenditure generating measurable social and economic value?


Another interesting example is Raghav Chadha, who qualified as a Chartered Accountant at the age of 22 before entering politics. His career illustrates a different route from professional finance to legislative politics.


These examples demonstrate that a CA entering politics does not necessarily leave the profession's principles behind. Instead, the professional mindset can be transferred to a much larger arena—the management of public money.


However, being a CA does not automatically make someone a better politician. Politics involves social issues, constitutional values, public sentiment and difficult compromises that cannot be solved through financial calculations alone. A successful political leader therefore needs to combine financial expertise with empathy, democratic values and an understanding of society.


There is also an important ethical dimension. Chartered Accountancy is a profession built on trust, independence and integrity. A CA entering politics must ensure that political interests do not compromise professional values. The credibility associated with the CA designation makes ethical conduct even more important in public life.


The real advantage of a CA in politics, therefore, is not simply knowledge of accounting. It is the habit of asking difficult questions: Where is the money coming from? Where is it going? What is the risk? Who is accountable? And is the expenditure producing the intended result?


India needs policymakers who can understand both people and numbers. The examples of Piyush Goyal and Raghav Chadha show that the transition from Chartered Accountancy to politics is possible and can create a valuable intersection between financial expertise and public policy.


Ultimately, the political role of a CA should not be viewed merely as a career change. It can be seen as an expansion of professional responsibility—from safeguarding the integrity of financial statements to contributing to the integrity of public finances.


The balance sheet of a company belongs to its shareholders. The balance sheet of a government belongs, in a broader sense, to the citizens.


And perhaps that is where the CA's political responsibility truly begins: making every public rupee count.


(The writer is a Chartered Accountant based in Thane. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page