top of page
Writer's pictureNilothpal Banerjee

Has IPL Become Indian Cricket’s Frankenstein’s Monster?

Cricket’s once-untouchable bastion, Test cricket, finds itself in a precarious position today. For generations, Test cricket was considered the purest form of the game, revered by former greats for its ability to showcase the sport’s depth of character and skill. It was a format that demanded patience, mental fortitude and tireless commitment. With no limits on overs or innings, the game unfolded at its own pace, allowing for strategic nuance and raw skill to dominate. Now, Test cricket’s charm has begun to wane, eclipsed by a faster-paced era that prioritizes entertainment over tradition.


India’s recent whitewash by New Zealand starkly highlighted the decline of domestic cricket, once a breeding ground for world-class talent. In 1987, despite losing a six-match Test series to Pakistan, Sunil Gavaskar’s masterclass of a knock on an unplayable track in Bangalore exemplified the resilience forged in India’s competitive domestic cricketing system. Unlike today, that defeat did not leave Indian cricket fans wringing their hands in despair.


The roots of this decline can be traced back to the colonial origins of Test cricket itself. Structured by the British, its format is undeniably traditional, with two innings spread across five days. Yet, even after enduring these gruelling lengths, a result is not always guaranteed, leaving fans disillusioned by the unpredictability of its outcomes. This structural flaw, left unaddressed for decades, robbed the format of its appeal, particularly in India, where commercial and entertainment values reign supreme. With Test cricket’s appeal diminishing, the economic viability of the format also took a hit, leading to lower salaries for players and a steady decline in its stature.


Enter Kerry Packer in 1977. The Australian media mogul’s World Series Cricket - featuring the fast-paced, limited 50-over format - offered a fresh alternative. Packer lured top-tier cricketers from the West Indies, Australia, Pakistan, and South Africa with lucrative contracts, a move that sent shockwaves through the cricketing world. As star players defected, Test cricket saw an exodus of talent, leaving the format floundering in its wake. While the dust eventually settled and players returned to international cricket by the late 1970s, one thing had irrevocably changed: one-day cricket, with its promise of action-packed contests, had captured the imagination of fans and players alike.


By 2008, the introduction of the Indian Premier League (IPL) would serve as the final blow to Test cricket’s prominence. The IPL, a 20-over format, offered astronomical sums of money, not just for elite players but for relatively unknown talent too. In the blink of an eye, the focus of budding Indian cricketers shifted from the traditional grind of first-class cricket and Test matches to the glitzy, high-reward world of the IPL. The lure of financial success and the ease of shorter formats meant that players were less inclined to endure the rigor of Test cricket.


Even more alarming is that the appeal of Test cricket among Indian fans has similarly dwindled. Earlier, a match between two Test-playing nations would fill stadiums. Now, the IPL has redefined what it means to watch cricket. The fast-paced nature of the T20 format, along with its franchise-based model, has fostered a fan base that is less concerned with national pride and more captivated by the spectacle. Youngsters in India now view the IPL as the pinnacle of success.


This trend isn’t unique to India; in countries like the West Indies and South Africa, players are increasingly opting for the financial rewards of T20 leagues over national representation, with pride in the national jersey giving way to lucrative contracts.


With the T20 juggernaut now firmly entrenched, is Test cricket doomed to fade into irrelevance? Should cricket boards across the world consider reforming the format into a more result-oriented, limited-over style to attract both players and spectators?


The answer may lie in reconciling the tradition of Test cricket with the demands of the commercialized cricketing landscape. If purists fail to adapt, Test cricket risks becoming the sport’s forgotten relic. India’s IPL has verily transformed into cricket’s Frankenstein’s monster - an uncontrollable force that threatens to consume the very fabric of the game it helped redefine.


(The author is a retired banker and cricket expert)

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page