In Maharashtra’s tangled electoral theater, Raj Thackeray’s Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) has again found itself caught in an uneasy tug-of-war with its nominal allies in the ruling Mahayuti coalition. In a high-profile debut, Raj’s son, Amit Thackeray, who is set to contest the Mahim Assembly seat, now finds himself facing a daunting challenge in a constituency marked by political crosscurrents and veiled grudges. The ruling MLA Sada Sarvankar of CM Eknath Shinde’s ruling Shiv Sena, has refused to back off despite previous intimations by the BJP that it would convince Sarvankar to withdraw.
Earlier, following Sarvankar’s intransigence, Raj Thackeray openly castigated Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar. His ire, stemmed from Shinde’s refusal to rein in Sarvankar, who flatly refused to step aside in favour of Amit.
Yet, despite venting his spleen on Shinde, Raj spared the BJP from any direct rebuke, hinting that his bonhomie with the saffron party remained intact.
However, the BJP appears to be doing a delicate balancing act over backing Amit Thackeray in Mahim.
While endorsing MNS candidates for only one seat—the Shivdi Assembly seat, where Raj Thackeray’s lieutenant Bala Nandgaonkar is contesting—it has maintained an ambiguous stance on supporting Amit in Mahim.
BJP’s Mumbai President Ashish Shelar clarified that their endorsement is limited strictly to Shivdi, effectively withdrawing the once-discussed support for Amit. Despite Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis’s efforts to broker a truce, BJP’s MLC Pravin Darekar highlighted that any backing for Amit in Mahim hinges on the Eknath Shiv Sena’s co-operation - a condition that underscores the BJP’s unwillingness to risk its alliances over Mahim.
This latest development has left Raj Thackeray navigating an uncertain political landscape with less than a fortnight to go for the polls. While the MNS leader campaigned fervently for Eknath Shinde’s son, Shrikant Shinde, in the recent Lok Sabha elections, Shinde’s refusal to reciprocate the same for Raj’s son in connection with the Mahim Assembly seat is likely to have stoked Raj’s frustrations.
For Amit, the upcoming contest marks a critical political debut as he faces not only Sarvankar but also the Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena (UBT) candidate Mahesh Sawant, creating a high-stakes triangular contest in central Mumbai. The MNS’ twin debacles in the 2014 parliamentary and Assembly elections left the party in utter disarray, with the slide continuing through the 2017 civic election as well as the 2019 State and national elections.
Following its rout in the 2019 Maharashtra Assembly election, an atrophied MNS had changed its ideological direction from its nativist stance by veering towards Hindutva politics, signalled by Mr. Raj Thackeray’s 2020 adoption of a saffron flag incorporating Chhatrapati Shivaji’s royal seal or ‘Rajmudra’.
The BJP’s reluctance to commit unequivocally to the MNS points to a larger strategy. By keeping its support conditional and focused on Nandgaonkar in Shivdi, the BJP retains leverage without alienating the Shinde faction—a tactical move to safeguard its alliance in Maharashtra’s fragmented political climate. For the BJP, Raj Thackeray’s Marathi vote bank remains valuable, but not indispensable.
The BJP thus benefits from Raj’s ideological alignment (the latter had offered unconditional support to the Mahayuti in the Lok Sabha), given his pivot towards Hindutva in the recent past. For the MNS and its leader, though, the Mahayuti’s ambivalence towards Raj Thackeray leaves the latter in a state of permanent political limbo.
Comments