top of page

By:

Abhijit Mulye

21 August 2024 at 11:29:11 am

Fadnavis writes off Rs 48,000 crore

Mumbai: In a clear indication that the Maharashtra government is leaving no stone unturned to keep the state’s agrarian base happy, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has unleashed yet another massive populist measure. Hot on the heels of relaxing the eligibility criteria to ensure a blanket farm loan waiver, the Chief Minister announced a sweeping Rs 48,000 crore waiver on the pending electricity bills of farmers across the state. Addressing a ‘Krutadnyata Sohala’ (gratitude ceremony)...

Fadnavis writes off Rs 48,000 crore

Mumbai: In a clear indication that the Maharashtra government is leaving no stone unturned to keep the state’s agrarian base happy, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has unleashed yet another massive populist measure. Hot on the heels of relaxing the eligibility criteria to ensure a blanket farm loan waiver, the Chief Minister announced a sweeping Rs 48,000 crore waiver on the pending electricity bills of farmers across the state. Addressing a ‘Krutadnyata Sohala’ (gratitude ceremony) organized by the BJP Kisan Morcha at Mumbai’s Yashwantrao Chavan Pratishthan on Wednesday, Fadnavis declared that farmers using agricultural pumps of up to 7.5 horsepower will see their historical electricity dues completely wiped out. The announcement was met with the traditional sounding of the Tutari and thunderous applause from hundreds of farmers who had gathered from every corner of the state. The Chief Minister framed the mega-sop as a necessary step to “wipe the farmers’ slate clean,” enabling them to write a new chapter of prosperity. Calculated Pitch The timing and scale of the announcement underscore a government that is boldly embracing populist economics to solidify its political footprint in rural Maharashtra. While Fadnavis maintained that these decisions were taken purely in the interest of the farmers—pointing out that the original loan waiver was announced when no elections were in sight—the political undertones were unmistakable. Taking a sharp dig at the opposition, the Chief Minister accused rival parties of running “political shops” in the name of farmer agitations without understanding the government’s genuine intent. Asserting his grassroots connection, Fadnavis proudly claimed, “I do not make decisions sitting in my house. I am a farmer myself, a man of the soil.” He openly defended the government’s recent move to strip away the stringent conditions attached to the blanket farm loan waiver, signaling that his administration will not hesitate to clear bureaucratic hurdles if it means putting money directly into the hands of the rural voter. Balancing Sops Even as he rained freebies, the Chief Minister attempted to balance the populist optics with a dose of economic pragmatism. He acknowledged that handing out repeated loan waivers is a symptom of deep-rooted agrarian distress, not a permanent cure. Pointing to the Rs 95,000 crore in aid currently being pumped into the agricultural sector by the state and central governments, Fadnavis outlined his administration’s shift toward an investment-driven agricultural model. He championed the success of schemes like ‘Jalyukt Shivar’ and ‘Magel Tyala Shettale’ (farm ponds on demand), claiming these initiatives have already empowered farmers to harvest multiple crops a year. Addressing the core issue of farming costs, he noted that the government already subsidises power to the tune of Rs 25,000 crore annually. By coupling this with a push for solar pumps and solar agricultural feeders, he promised that 100 percent of the state’s farmers would receive uninterrupted daytime electricity by the end of the year. Infra Dream Looking beyond immediate financial relief, the Chief Minister laid out a grandiose vision to permanently drought-proof Maharashtra’s most vulnerable regions. A staggering Rs 6 lakh crore infrastructure pipeline is being planned to ensure the next generation never witnesses a drought. Fadnavis detailed ambitious river-linking projects, including the Wainganga-Nalganga link, to divert excess floodwaters to parched regions. The state plans to construct 24 new dams and raise the height of 16 existing ones to ensure not a single district in Vidarbha faces water scarcity. Furthermore, massive engineering feats are on the drawing board to divert 200 TMC of floodwater from Western Maharashtra to Marathwada, and lift 275 TMC of wasted water from the Ulhas basin to quench the thirst of North Maharashtra and Marathwada. By marrying immediate, massive debt relief with long-term infrastructure promises, the Fadnavis administration is aggressively cementing its pro-farmer narrative. As the Yashwantrao Chavan auditorium echoed with whistles and cheers, it became highly evident that the government’s strategy of pairing mega populist waivers with big-ticket rural dreams is striking a powerful chord with the state’s agrarian voters.

Mumbai’s Water Wake-Up Call

Chennai responded to its water crisis with long-term investments, while Mumbai continues to rely primarily on reservoirs and seasonal rainfall.

Every summer, Mumbai faces concerns over its water supply as reservoir levels decline and the city waits for the arrival of the monsoon. This year has been no different, with the city once again imposing water supply cuts. The move has reignited debate over Mumbai's long-term water security and its continued dependence on seasonal rainfall.


Recurring Crisis

With reservoir levels falling and the monsoon yet to arrive, concerns over water availability have intensified across Mumbai. The situation was further complicated by a strike by water tanker operators, while civic authorities responded with supply restrictions and conservation measures. Among them was a 20 per cent reduction in water allocated to industrial units, commercial establishments and sports clubs.


Yet the larger question remains largely unaddressed: why does a city with more than 150 kilometres of coastline continue to face recurring water shortages whenever monsoon rainfall falls short of expectations?


Mumbai is India's financial capital and receives substantial annual rainfall. With more than 150 kilometres of Arabian Sea coastline, the city would appear well-positioned to ensure water security. Yet its water supply remains heavily dependent on reservoirs and the monsoon.


A weak monsoon, prolonged dry spell or the growing impact of climate change can quickly push Mumbai towards a water crisis.


Yet another coastal city faced a similar challenge and chose a different path. Chennai acted. Mumbai now faces a similar choice.


Chennai's Lesson

Chennai, too, once struggled with severe water shortages. In 2019, its reservoirs nearly ran dry, bringing the city to the brink of a major water crisis.


Instead of remaining dependent on rainfall alone, Chennai invested in long-term water security measures. Desalination became a key part of its strategy, alongside rainwater harvesting, wastewater recycling and groundwater recharge initiatives.


The city recently commissioned the Perur Desalination Plant, which will add 400 million litres of drinking water a day to its supply network.


Once operational, Chennai's total desalination capacity will reach about 750 million litres per day, strengthening its position as India's leading desalination hub. Chennai's experience offers an important lesson: coastal cities have options if they are willing to invest in long-term water security.


Mumbai and Chennai share many similarities. Both are large coastal metros with populations exceeding 10 million and remain heavily dependent on the monsoon. The difference is that Chennai responded to its water crisis with long-term investments, while Mumbai continues to rely primarily on reservoirs and seasonal rainfall.


Beyond Monsoons

Mumbai's water strategy remains heavily dependent on reservoirs, lakes and seasonal rainfall, despite the city being surrounded by the Arabian Sea.


Desalination is no longer an experimental solution. Countries such as Israel, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, Australia and the UAE rely on desalinated water as a dependable source of urban supply. Chennai has also demonstrated how desalination can become an integral part of a city's water security strategy.


The question is whether Mumbai is prepared to make similar investments before shortages become more frequent and severe.


Future Risks

The question is not whether Mumbai will face water shortages, but how severe those shortages could become in the years ahead.


Climate change is making monsoon patterns increasingly unpredictable. Population growth, rising industrial demand and declining groundwater levels are placing additional pressure on existing water sources.


Continued dependence on reservoirs and seasonal rainfall leaves the city vulnerable to recurring water stress. Diversifying water sources has therefore become a necessity rather than an option. Water security will ultimately require a combination of measures, including desalination, wastewater recycling, rainwater harvesting, groundwater recharge and improvements to distribution infrastructure.


Desalination offers one such alternative. In addition to supplementing drinking water supplies, it can reduce pressure on reservoirs, support industrial demand and strengthen resilience during years of below-normal rainfall.


The technology is neither new nor untested. Countries such as Israel, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, Australia and the UAE have integrated desalination into their long-term water security strategies. During his 2017 visit to Israel, Prime Minister Narendra Modi was shown desalination technologies capable of converting seawater into potable water efficiently and at scale.


Mumbai has repeatedly demonstrated its ability to execute complex infrastructure projects, from the Bandra-Worli Sea Link to the Metro network and the Coastal Road. Water security deserves the same long-term vision and commitment.


It is time for the Maharashtra government and the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to move beyond short-term measures and adopt a comprehensive water security strategy that combines desalination, rainwater harvesting, wastewater recycling, groundwater recharge and infrastructure upgrades.


The choice is clear: continue relying primarily on the monsoon, or invest now in a more resilient and secure water future.


(The author is a resident of Mumbai. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page