top of page

By:

Abhijit Mulye

21 August 2024 at 11:29:11 am

Inside the secret power struggle behind Dhankhar’s resignation

Mumbai: The cryptic silence surrounding the abrupt resignation of former Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar in July was shattered on the floor of the Rajya Sabha this Monday, not by a government clarification, but by the visible anguish of the Opposition. While official records continue to attribute his departure to “health reasons,” highly placed sources in the power corridors of the capital have now confirmed that a fatal misunderstanding of the shifting power dynamics between the Rashtriya...

Inside the secret power struggle behind Dhankhar’s resignation

Mumbai: The cryptic silence surrounding the abrupt resignation of former Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar in July was shattered on the floor of the Rajya Sabha this Monday, not by a government clarification, but by the visible anguish of the Opposition. While official records continue to attribute his departure to “health reasons,” highly placed sources in the power corridors of the capital have now confirmed that a fatal misunderstanding of the shifting power dynamics between the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) top brass was the true precipice from which the former Vice President fell. The revelations surfaced as the Winter Session of Parliament commenced on Monday, December 1, 2025. The solemnity of welcoming the new Vice President and Rajya Sabha Chairman, C.P. Radhakrishnan, was punctured by an emotional intervention from Leader of the Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge. The veteran Congress leader, hands shaking and voice trembling, shed tears on the floor of the House—a rare display of vulnerability that underscored the Opposition’s grievance over what they term an “institutional surgical strike.” The Failed Mediation Exclusive details emerging from Delhi’s political circles paint a picture of a constitutional authority who misread the winds of change. Sources reveal that tensions between Dhankhar and the government had been simmering for months, primarily over his handling of key legislative agendas and a perceived “drift” towards accommodating Opposition demands in the Upper House. As the chasm widened, a lifeline was reportedly thrown. A senior leader from a prominent alliance partner within the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) — a figure with decades of parliamentary experience and respect across the aisle — had discreetly offered to mediate. This leader recognized the growing impatience in the BJP high command and sought to bridge the gap before it became unbridgeable. However, Dhankhar declined the immediate urgency of this political mediation. “He was confident in his equations with the ideological parent,” a source familiar with the developments stated. “He is close to some of the RSS top functionaries and relied on them to mediate when his equations with the BJP top brass started going astray.” This reliance on Nagpur to manage New Delhi proved to be a critical miscalculation. Sources indicate that Dhankhar believed his deep ties with the Sangh would act as a buffer, insulating him from the political maneuvering of the ruling party’s executive leadership. He reportedly waited for the “green signal” or intervention from RSS functionaries, delaying the necessary reconciliation with the party leadership. Cost of delay The delay in mending ways was fatal. By the time the former Vice President realized that the RSS would not—or could not—overrule the BJP’s strategic decision to replace him, the die had been cast. The drift had become a gulf. The instruction, when it finally came on that fateful July 21, was absolute - he had to vacate the office immediately. The “untimely sudden resignation” that followed was officially cloaked in medical terminology, but insiders describe a chaotic exit. The former VP, who had recently moved into the lavish new Vice-President’s Enclave, was forced to vacate the premises in haste, leaving behind a tenure marked by both assertive confrontations and, ironically, a final act of silent compliance. Tears in the Upper House The ghost of this departure loomed large over Monday’s proceedings. Welcoming the new Chairman, C.P. Radhakrishnan, Mallikarjun Kharge could not hold back his emotions. Breaking away from the customary pleasantries, Kharge launched into a poignant lament for the predecessor who was denied a farewell. “I am constrained to refer to your predecessor’s completely unexpected and sudden exit from the office of the Rajya Sabha Chairman, which is unprecedented in the annals of parliamentary history,” Kharge said, his voice heavy with emotion. As Treasury benches erupted in protest, shouting slogans to drown out the discomforting truth, Kharge continued, wiping tears from his eyes. “The Chairman, being the custodian of the entire House, belongs as much to the Opposition as to the government. I was disheartened that the House did not get an opportunity to bid him a farewell. Regardless, we wish him, on behalf of the entire Opposition, a very healthy life.” The sight of the Leader of the Opposition shedding tears for a presiding officer with whom he had frequently clashed was a striking paradox. It highlighted the Opposition’s narrative that Dhankhar’s removal was not just a personnel change, but an assertion of executive dominance over the legislature. New chapter with old scars The government, represented by Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju, sharply countered Kharge’s remarks, accusing the Opposition of shedding “crocodile tears” after having moved impeachment notices against Dhankhar in the past. “You are insulting the Chair by raising this now,” Rijiju argued amidst the din. Yet, outside the House, the whispers persisted. The narrative of a Vice President who waited for a call from Nagpur that came too late has firmly taken root. As C.P. Radhakrishnan takes the Chair, he does so not just as a new presiding officer, but as the successor to a man who learned the hard way that in the current dispensation, political alignment with the executive supersedes even the oldest of ideological ties.

Seeking the Sacred: A Gen Z Pilgrim’s Mahakumbh Odyssey

Updated: Mar 3

A journey through faith, mysticism and the unexpected at the world’s largest spiritual gathering.

Gen Z Pilgrim

I’ve never been the archetypal religious person. Although I identify as a Hindu, my understanding of it is quite limited. I grew up learning a few shlokas and aartis, mostly the ones that my parents used to recite. I often prayed, sometimes even trying to bargain with God for good marks or a crush’s attention.


My view of Hinduism was shaped by my family and surroundings. I followed the rituals they did and prayed to the Gods I saw in my home. This covered a total of 10- 15 Gods from the massive repository of 330 million. I am not entirely sure what drew me to the Maha Kumbh. There were claims about it being a myth, a political masterstroke or a way to absolve one’s past misdeeds.


I’m neither politically inclined nor overly ritualistic, but curiosity got the best of me. After all, why would a third of India’s population gather at the confluence of rivers during peak winters for a mere dip!?


I had planned to spend two days in Prayag - one for the holy dip and one to visit the akharas. On the first, the only goal was reaching the Sangam. With vehicles banned from the inner city, the walk through the Kumbh Mela’s throng became an experience in itself. A vast, surging crowd moved in unison - young and old, rich and poor - towards the sacred confluence. Despite the crush, hospitality flourished. Locals distributed food and tea, helped the elderly on scooters, and reunited lost pilgrims via loudspeakers.


The Sangam was more than the meeting of rivers; it was a confluence of cultures. South Indians in veshtis, Rajasthanis in bright lehengas and pagdis, Bengalis in red-and-white sarees, and people like me, more comfortable in cargo pants - all drawn towards the same sacred waters regardless of attire. VIP boats floated nearby, but the real pilgrimage was here, shoulder to shoulder with strangers, bound by faith and the pull of something greater than themselves.


Everyone was absorbed in their own version of devotion. Some filmed vlogs and clicked pictures, others filled bottles with holy water. Some performed puja, while others tossed coins into the river - only for a few to dive in and collect them. There were those playfully splashing around, claiming they were now ‘sin-free’ and ready for fresh ones, while others kept immersing themselves over and over - perhaps as insurance for future misdeeds.


There was no single right way to dress, pray, or even behave at the Sangam. Each person followed their own belief, doing what felt right in that moment, in that sacred space.


On my way back, I saw a massive gathering of ascetics from various akharas lining up for their holy bat. Although I knew little about them, I couldn’t help but admire the striking diversity. Some were completely naked, covered in ash, and carrying weapons; others dressed in all-black, while many wore the familiar saffron robes, radiating warmth with their bright smiles.


On my way back, I saw stalls catering to every income segment - vendors sold chana and puri for as little as Rs. 10, while Domino’s offered pan pizzas for Rs. 100.


There were free tent accommodations, hundreds of mobile toilets, and water dispensers along the way. Yet, despite these arrangements, filth was inevitable. Some toilets were so foul-smelling that I wouldn’t dare to use them.


But with a third of India’s population descending upon a small city, no amount of cleaning would ever be enough without civic responsibility from the masses. It wasn’t surprising, just a stark reminder of the scale of this grand gathering.


Day two began without a clear plan. I didn’t know the names of the akharas or where to find them, and even if I did, I had no set agenda or burning questions.


Still, I made my way to the other side, where the akharas housed ascetics during the Kumbh. Being a digital native, I was familiar with some of the ‘celebrities’ of the Kumbh - the IIT Baba, the Baba with a pigeon on his head and so on.


With no specific goal, I decided to track one of them down and soon found the Baba with a pigeon on his head. He was moving swiftly from one lane to another, and a small group of us instinctively followed, trying to keep up.

We were so fixated on him that we didn’t notice shards of glass on the road. Ironically, he was the one to stop, point them out, clean them, and scold us for being too absorbed in ourselves to see potential harm to others.


Along the way, I came across many ascetics smoking marijuana and performing rituals unfamiliar to me but seemingly normal to others. Having grown up in an environment where smoking was a strict no, it was both shocking and fascinating to see a religion embrace practices that might seem unconventional but are accepted as long as they aid in the pursuit of the ultimate truth.


The next akhara I visited was one often linked to the mysterious and the unknown - the Aghor Akhara. Men dressed in black, rudraksha malas around their necks, kohl-rimmed eyes, and skulls placed around their sacred space. Despite their intimidating appearance, they sat patiently, answering every question posed by curious visitors. Even those associated with so-called ‘dark sciences’ welcomed open conversations with anyone willing to engage. I was lucky to witness a small music event inside the akhara, where men and women sang an aarti dedicated to Lord Shiva. Music and dance have always been an integral part of our culture, but seeing this fusion of melodious devotion intertwined with what I had previously perceived as ‘dark sciences’ helped shatter my long-held stereotypes.


Right next to this akhara was ISKCON, known for the bhakti pathway and its global following. Their setup was entirely dedicated to Krishna, complete with life-like statues of the God to enhance the experience. Here too, people were singing and dancing, but in a more public, celebratory manner. Finally, I visited the Nath akhara which was filled with ascetics dressed in saffron, each minding their own. I even received an appy juice as prasad and had some enlightening conversation with one of the ascetics who patiently answered every question I posed.


Each akhara I visited had its own traditions, distinct ways of praying, dressing, and even different chosen deities. Shiva, Vishnu, Krishna, Kali, Guru Gobind Singh - all had dedicated akharas. Yet, despite their differences, they coexisted peacefully, without debates over whose God or method was superior.


Not every ascetic isolated themselves in a Himalayan cave for years, meditating until they re-emerge at the Kumbh to observe the world. Some travelled across India, organizing fairs to uplift local economies, engaging in charity, or even taking on roles of social and political leadership. Many had advanced degrees, Instagram accounts and active WhatsApp numbers. They were ordinary people who had chosen a spiritual life over a conventional one.


Shashi Tharoor described Hinduism as a henotheistic religion, one that focuses on a supreme principle while respecting the existence of multiple deities and pathways. The Kumbh is a celebration of this diversity - where every path is respected, every seeker accepted and every sincere contribution to understanding the ultimate truth is celebrated. Hinduism isn’t a one-size-fits-all faith; it offers the freedom to choose the path that resonates most with an individual. The foundation remains the same, but the paths are many and within them lies the essence of true spiritual liberty.


(The author is an MBA from IIM Calcutta. She is currently working at Boston Consulting Group, Mumbai. A dedicated dancer for over 14 years she is passionate about exploring new places and experiences.)

Comments


bottom of page