top of page

By:

Quaid Najmi

4 January 2025 at 3:26:24 pm

MVA protests for third day:

Mumbai: The Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA) allies continued their agitation for the third day in different parts of Maharashtra with an aggressive state Congress hitting the streets today to protest the detention of Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, his sister Priyanka Gandhi-Vadra and other Congress leaders yesterday, here on Wednesday. State and city Youth Congress again carried out vociferous protests near Mantralaya raising slogans, carrying banners and placards slamming the...

MVA protests for third day:

Mumbai: The Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA) allies continued their agitation for the third day in different parts of Maharashtra with an aggressive state Congress hitting the streets today to protest the detention of Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, his sister Priyanka Gandhi-Vadra and other Congress leaders yesterday, here on Wednesday. State and city Youth Congress again carried out vociferous protests near Mantralaya raising slogans, carrying banners and placards slamming the state and central Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), and when some attempted to enter inside, they were prevented by a strong posse of Mumbai Police deployed there since Monday. As tensions appeared to escalate, the police clamped down by detaining top state and city Youth Congress leaders including President Harshwardhan Sapkal, Vijay Wadettiwar, Bhai Jagtap, Hussain Dalwai, and many others. Thousands of students carried out a fresh demonstration at Dadar west Shivaji Park to vent their ire at the police action on Cockroach Janta Party (CJP)’s agitation in New Delhi on Monday. Several MVA leaders and Maharashtra Navnirman Sena chief Raj Thackeray visited or expressed solidarity with the protesting youth, comprising many women. Opposition’s Voice The Congress leaders alleged that Rahul Gandhi was targeted by the BJP-led government to muzzle democratic dissent, suppress the Opposition voices inside and outside Parliament and trampling upon the peoples' Constitutional Rights to protest peacefully. Defying pouring rains in the city on Wednesday, Congress workers along with activists of MVA allies, staged a noisy demonstration in Chembur and another group attempted to storm the BJP office in south Mumbai, condemning the assault on students in New Delhi and the detention of the Gandhi siblings. Senior Congress leader Hussain Dalwai flayed the government for “misusing the police” to gag democratic rights and the protests were intended to defend the Constitution and democracy against the BJP’s policy of intolerance of dissent in any form. “This is gross injustice. We are not allowed to protest against the government failures as they are misusing the police. The PM is scared of taking the resignation of Dharmendra Pradhan as he could be the next. We want to highlight to the BJP to govern the country as per the Constitution,” Dalwai declared, interacting with the media at Nariman Point. As the BJP also threatened to launch counter-protests, the police cordoned off and deployed a precautionary security ring around Tilak Bhavan, the state Congress headquarters, as leaders from both sides exchanged political darts and looked aggressive enough for a confrontation. MVA ‘bandh’, ‘Tricolour’ march today The state is set for another two days of political turmoil as the MVA has announced a Maharashtra shutdown (‘bandh’) on Thursday followed by a non-partisan ‘Tricolour Peace March’ on Friday. MVA allies, Vanchit Bahujan Aghadi (VBA) President Prakash Ambedkar and Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Aaditya Thackeray, besides other leaders of the alliance, informed of the state and city level actions today. Ambedkar appealed to the masses and also the BJP youth to participate wholeheartedly in the bandh tomorrow and claimed that students’ bodies, parent-teachers associations, colleges, universities, other institutes of higher education, private coaching institutions, and other governmental departments could support the shutdown, as it has now become a national issue. Aaditya sought the peoples’ participation in the ‘Tricolour Peace March’ on the theme of “One Nation, One Emotion” planned on July 24 afternoon to Shivaji Park, in support of environmentalist Sonam Wangchuk, the Cockroach Janta Party, plus the youth and students protesting in New Delhi. Terming it as a national citizens’ movement rather than a political party, he called upon the people not to carry any party flags but unite under the National Tricolour to assert democratic rights and express resentment against the government’s high-handed policies. Meanwhile, Mumbai Police have already imposed prohibitory orders under Section 144 across the city from July 23-to- August 6, apprehending the possibility of law-and-order disturbances.

The Convenience Economy

India’s booming lifestyle management industry is a symptom of the state’s withdrawal from care infrastructure.

AI generated image
AI generated image

An IIT-founder CEO in Gurugram pays Rs. 1 lakh a month to a single person who manages his laundry, food, wardrobe, domestic staff training, and household repairs. In Bengaluru, a young professional couple uses a lifestyle management firm to coordinate their home schedules, travel bookings and vendor calls. These are not outliers but the visible edge of a formalising industry now present across India’s metros.


The lifestyle management market in India was valued at USD 2.8 billion in 2025. It is projected to reach USD 5.9 billion by 2034, growing at 8.6 percent annually, according to market research firm Dataintelo. Job portals currently list 1,094 lifestyle manager positions across India with 203 in Bengaluru alone. Salaries for these positions range from Rs. 16 lakh to Rs. 49 lakh annually, with an average of Rs 19.2 lakh.


Lifestyle managers handle tasks that should, in a functioning public infrastructure, be less burdensome. Eldercare, childcare coordination, household staff oversight. The wealthy have outsourced these to a professional class. Everyone else absorbs the work informally, mostly women.


The National Statistics Office Time Use Survey 2024 released by MoSPI in February 2025 shows women in India spend 289 minutes per day on unpaid domestic services, compared to 88 minutes for men. Women spend an additional 137 minutes daily on unpaid caregiving for household members, against 75 minutes for men. This is a structural transfer of public goods responsibility onto individual households, and within households, onto women.


The Ministry of Women and Child Development has estimated that women's unpaid domestic and care work represents 15 to 17 percent of India's GDP. India spends less than one percent of GDP on public care infrastructure. The arithmetic is not difficult.


Labour Hierarchies

The lifestyle management industry has formalised one tier of care work while leaving the other entirely unprotected. Lifestyle managers earn huge salaries and receive employment benefits. The domestic workers they are hired to supervise and coordinate fall into a completely different legal category.


India has between 25-80 million domestic workers depending on the estimate, making it the largest employer of domestic workers in the world. The country has not ratified ILO Convention 189 on Decent Work for Domestic Workers, adopted in 2011. India supported the Convention at the International Labour Conference but has not enacted national legislation in the 15 years since. The government's stated reason is that existing legal frameworks do not meet C189’s requirements. It has not changed those frameworks either.


The four Labour Codes enacted from 2019 to 2020 include domestic workers in their scope but provide no specific enforcement mechanisms, wage floors, or social security pathways for this sector. Karnataka introduced a draft Domestic Workers Welfare Bill in 2025 that mandates employer registration, written contracts, and welfare fund contributions. It has not been implemented nationally. Tamil Nadu has a welfare board, but registration is low and minimum wage compliance is weak.


This two-tier structure is not accidental. JNU economist Avinash Kumar, quoted in a recent report, described the process as ‘precarisation’ where digital platforms, uniforms, and ratings systems create an appearance of formal employment without improving actual working conditions. The lifestyle management firm intermediates between the wealthy client and the domestic worker.


The UBS Global Wealth Report 2025 places India eighth among the ten most unequal countries in its sample of 56 nations. India’s Gini coefficient for wealth stands at 0.74, identical to the United States, a country with significantly higher average income and social protection spending. India added 39,000 dollar millionaires in 2024, bringing the total to 917,000. Over the same period, its real average wealth per adult declined.


Unprotected Workers

In India’s burgeoning lifestyle-management industry, clients pay anything between Rs. 15,000-1.5 lakh a month for convenience. Demand is buoyed by a rapidly expanding class of ultra-rich; Knight Frank expects India to record the world’s fastest growth in ultra-high-net-worth individuals between 2023 and 2028. Yet the workforce underpinning this economy remains largely unprotected, with no guaranteed minimum wage, weekly rest or access to provident-fund and insurance benefits without formal contracts. The Union Budget 2026-27 proposes training 1.5 lakh multiskilled caregivers, but leaves untouched the status of 10.4 lakh ASHA and 25 lakh Anganwadi workers, who continue to deliver frontline health and nutrition services as ‘volunteers’ rather than employees.


The E-Shram portal has expanded documentation of informal workers. Registration is not protection. A domestic worker registered on E-Shram has no legal wage floor if the state government has not notified one, no enforceable rest periods, and no grievance mechanism beyond civil courts that are inaccessible to workers paid Rs. 6,000 a month.


There is no GST enforcement mechanism for the premium lifestyle management market, no mandatory disclosure requirement for firms on how they classify and pay the workers they supply to clients, and no inclusion of domestic work in the Smart Cities Mission or affordable housing planning frameworks.


India’s female labour force participation rate was 25 percent in 2024 for women aged 15 to 59, up from 21.8 percent in 2019 per the NSO Time Use Survey. The gap with men, at 75 percent, remains 50 percentage points wide. Multiple studies link this gap directly to the unequal burden of unpaid care work. McKinsey Global Institute has estimated that robust investment in India’s care economy could increase GDP by 60 percent if women’s labour force participation reaches parity.


Instead, what is happening is a market solution for the top 0.1 percent and no solution for anyone else. The wealthy hire lifestyle managers. Everyone else absorbs the work. The state counts neither as an economic contribution nor a policy responsibility.


India’s lifestyle manager industry is not evidence of prosperity. It is evidence of what happens when public care infrastructure is absent, labour law excludes the most vulnerable workers, and wealth concentrates at a rate that allows a small fraction of the population to buy their way out of the obligations the state has not met.


(The writer is an independent public policy researcher. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page