top of page

By:

Minal Sancheti

2 May 2026 at 12:26:53 pm

Tussle between BMC, WR leaves Dadar dry

Mumbai: Dadar is the only railway station in Mumbai that has no authorised water connection. This, as per the sources, is due to an ongoing dispute between the Western Railway and the BMC. The tussle between the BMC and the Western Railway has led to a strange situation. The Western Railway is asking the BMC to pay Rs 338 crore for way leave charges, and the Western Railway has to pay Rs 22 Lakh to the BMC. The tussle has been going on for 12 years and remains unresolved. As per the sources,...

Tussle between BMC, WR leaves Dadar dry

Mumbai: Dadar is the only railway station in Mumbai that has no authorised water connection. This, as per the sources, is due to an ongoing dispute between the Western Railway and the BMC. The tussle between the BMC and the Western Railway has led to a strange situation. The Western Railway is asking the BMC to pay Rs 338 crore for way leave charges, and the Western Railway has to pay Rs 22 Lakh to the BMC. The tussle has been going on for 12 years and remains unresolved. As per the sources, due to this, the BMC has not given any new connections to the Western Railway, which needs the connections because of the increase in the capacity of new coaches. Currently, the Western Railway is facing a water shortage of 20 per cent for train operations. Thus, the water is being filled at the next train stops like Surat and Valsad, or wherever the train halts. The dependency on water tankers has increased because the Western Railway did not have enough water connections from the BMC. This has caused more expenditure for the Western Railway. For Dadar terminus, the Western Railway uses 40 water tankers, each water tanker of the capacity of 10,000 litres, which comes down to four lakh litres of water every day. Around eight water tankers of the capacity of 10,000 litres, which comes down to 80,000 litres of water, are required for Dadar station. In total, the Western Railway incurs expenses on 4,80,000 litres of water every day. BMC PRO Tanaji Kamble has denied that there was no water connection at Dadar Railway Station. “Every station has BMC water connection,” he said. Chief Public Relations Officer (CPRO) of Western Railway Vineet Abhishek said, “All efforts are being taken to ensure there is no inconvenience to our passengers.”

Some lessons from recent violence in Nagpur

Updated: Mar 23, 2025

  • Social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram are being increasingly used to incite persons of certain community in couple of hours without any apparent preparation. Similar situation prevailed in riots in Bangalore & Delhi in recent past.

  • Vehicles like tractor trollies full of huge stones were rushed in from neighbouring outside places in a particular direction with a target of attacking particular community

  • Houses identified by Tulsi and vehicles having Ganesh idols were subjected to brutality & arson

  • Police officers were subjected to violent attacks including by axe, stones and swords

  • Swords from ancient period were available with a section of attackers. These continue to be stored unchecked.


    Lessons:

    Continuous monitoring of social media platforms either technically or by being members of groups run by suspected persons

  • Enforcing ‘Nakabandi’ to check movement of vehicles & suspicious persons towards a particular direction suddenly

  • Keeping adequate reserve police squads equipped with riot control equipment including helmets, shields, tear gas , and weapons to meet any contingency in sensitive police stations

  • Have ‘police mitra’ in huge numbers who can inform police about suspicious developments in advance and also work with police during riots

  • Police officers should not rush to such spots without helmet and adequately prepared , else they are victims and sustain serious injuries or even deaths

  • Constant dialogue with sensible leaders to avoid flaring up of tempers

  • Instruct corporation officers to ensure no construction material is allowed on roads as the same can be used as missiles

  • Remove road blockades including tyres regularly as it hinders movement of police, fire brigade and ambulances in emergency

  • Continuous preventive action against known bad elements who take disadvantage of such situations and create ruckus

  • Have regular mock drills , once in six months , by police even when there is peace to face such violent situations

  • Police also need to be more equipped during the month of Ramzan as most of the riots have taken place during this period. This is allegedly linked to incitement in the name of battle of Badr, where on 17 th day of Ramazan Prophet Mohammad had attacked his enemies at Badr.


(The author is a former Director General of Police, Maharashtra.)

Comments

bottom of page