top of page

By:

Dr. Abhilash Dawre

19 March 2025 at 5:18:41 pm

Woman held for allegedly killing daughter

She was reportedly upset over her love relationship with a man from other caste Ulhasnagar: In a shocking incident that has sent shockwaves across Ulhasnagar, a mother allegedly strangled her 19-year-old daughter to death after opposing her relationship with a young man from another caste. According to the police, the accused, identified as Asha Garad, allegedly killed her daughter Amruta Garad in a fit of rage when the latter was preparing to leave home with the man she was in a relationship...

Woman held for allegedly killing daughter

She was reportedly upset over her love relationship with a man from other caste Ulhasnagar: In a shocking incident that has sent shockwaves across Ulhasnagar, a mother allegedly strangled her 19-year-old daughter to death after opposing her relationship with a young man from another caste. According to the police, the accused, identified as Asha Garad, allegedly killed her daughter Amruta Garad in a fit of rage when the latter was preparing to leave home with the man she was in a relationship with. The accused has been arrested by Ulhasnagar Police Station No. 1, and further investigation is underway. According to the police, the incident took place at Bhaiyyasaheb Ambedkar Nagar in Ulhasnagar Camp No. 1, where Amruta Garad lived with her family. She was reportedly in a relationship with a young man from another caste who resided in the same neighbourhood. Her mother strongly opposed the relationship and had repeatedly tried to convince her to end it. However, Amruta remained firm in her decision. Police said that at around 1:30 am on Sunday night, a heated argument broke out between the mother and daughter while Amruta's father and two brothers were asleep in the house. Following the argument, Amruta was allegedly preparing to leave home with the young man. At that moment, Asha Garad allegedly used a scarf to strangle her daughter, resulting in her death on the spot. After the incident, Amruta's father approached Ulhasnagar Police Station No. 1 and informed the police about the incident. Police immediately reached the spot, conducted a panchnama, and sent the body to the Central Hospital, Ulhasnagar, for post-mortem examination. Based on the preliminary investigation, police registered a case against Asha Garad and arrested her. The incident, in which a mother allegedly killed her own daughter, has created widespread shock in the Ulhasnagar area. Further investigation is being carried out by officers of Ulhasnagar Police Station No. 1. While speaking to ‘The Perfect Voice’, Deputy Commissioner of Police Sachin Gore said that the 19-year-old woman's mother was opposed to her love marriage. Following an argument, the mother allegedly killed her daughter in a fit of rage. A case has been registered at Ulhasnagar Police Station No. 1, the accused woman has been arrested, and further investigation is in progress.

The Body Politic of Farming

For decades, India has approached food security as an engineering problem. Governments built granaries, expanded irrigation canals, subsidised fertilisers and fretted over logistics networks that could carry onions from Nashik or tomatoes from Kolar to distant urban markets. The vocabulary of policy was dominated by procurement, storage and distribution. Food security was measured in tonnes. Risk was measured in rainfall deficits. The farmer, paradoxically, was treated as incidental to the system he sustained.


But today, the deeper fragility of India’s food economy is no longer merely climatic or logistical; it is biological. Beneath the discussions on Minimum Support Prices (MSP), cold-storage chains and export bans lies a neglected reality: the exhaustion of the human being at the centre of agricultural production. India has long monitored the depreciation of tractors and the degradation of soil. It has paid far less attention to the “biological depreciation” of the farmer himself.


As an agricultural expert with decades of experience, I have articulated a Farmers’ Health Capital Theory to remedy this. The theory argues that a farmer’s physical and mental health should be treated not as a welfare concern alone, but as a measurable economic asset essential to national stability.


Every economic system recognises maintenance costs. Factories budget for machinery breakdowns. Airlines inspect aircraft engines before failure occurs. Even digital companies invest heavily in server resilience and redundancy. Agriculture, however, continues to operate as though the human body powering it were infinitely renewable.


India’s farm economy remains heavily dependent on intense manual labour, especially in high-value perishable crops such as tomatoes, onions and potatoes—the politically sensitive ‘TOP’ crops that periodically convulse inflation charts and television studios alike. Conventional explanations for price spikes usually point to erratic monsoons, hoarding middlemen or transport disruptions. Yet a closer examination of conditions at the farm gate reveals a subtler bottleneck: physical exhaustion.


Extreme heat provides the clearest example. During severe temperature spells, a farmer’s productivity collapses abruptly. Manual picking slows. Delays that appear trivial in isolation become economically catastrophic in aggregate. A delay of even two days in harvesting tomatoes can sharply reduce usable yield through spoilage and overripening. In a tightly balanced market, small production losses at the source cascade into dramatic retail inflation in cities hundreds of kilometres away.


Thus, the vulnerability of India’s food system may lie not merely in weather patterns, but in the physiological limits of the people exposed to them.


The traditional state response to volatility is infrastructural expansion: build more warehouses, increase buffer stocks, tighten supply chains. Those measures remain necessary, but they address the symptoms rather than the origin of instability. A Health Capital approach would focus upstream, on preserving the reliability of the “human engine” that drives production itself.


That could mean investment in mechanised harvesting tools suited to small landholdings, heat-shielding infrastructure, hydration systems, portable shade technologies and rural health protocols specifically tailored to agricultural labour conditions. Such interventions are often dismissed as welfare expenditures. In reality, they may prove as strategically important as fertiliser subsidies or irrigation projects.


This logic also casts existing welfare schemes in a different light. Programmes such as PM-KISAN are typically framed as income support or political largesse. But viewed through the prism of Health Capital Theory, they resemble maintenance liquidity for the nation’s food infrastructure. Financial buffers allow farmers to avoid cutting back on nutrition, delaying medical treatment or overextending physical labour during periods of stress.


A healthier farmer is not merely a happier citizen. He is also less likely to make costly agronomic errors, mishandle pesticides, neglect crop supervision or abandon cultivation altogether.


If crop prices fail to compensate for the biological recovery of those producing them, the country is effectively extracting value by depleting its own human capital base. Rural migration is often analysed through the lens of income disparities and urban aspiration. Yet physical depletion is equally important. When farming becomes synonymous with bodily attrition and financial precarity, younger generations rationally abandon it. The result is not merely demographic change, but a slow erosion of domestic production capacity.


India’s food-security challenge, then, is not only about producing enough grain. It is about sustaining the biological resilience of those who produce it.


The country has spent decades treating farmers as beneficiaries of policy. It may now need to regard them instead as custodians of critical national infrastructure.


(The writer is a member of Maharashtra Agriculture Price Commission. Views personal.)


Comments


bottom of page