top of page

By:

Correspondent

21 August 2024 at 10:20:16 am

Holy Contracts

The Kumbh Mela is supposed to be a celebration of faith. But in Maharashtra, it is beginning to look rather too much like an opportunity for fraudsters. For the BJP-led Mahayuti, the alleged Kumbh Mela scam is a potentially damaging test of political credibility and an unwelcome headache for Minister Girish Mahajan. The arrest of Tanay Mahajan, described as a distant relative of the Minister, in an alleged racket involving fake Kumbh work orders has handed the Opposition an opportunity it...

Holy Contracts

The Kumbh Mela is supposed to be a celebration of faith. But in Maharashtra, it is beginning to look rather too much like an opportunity for fraudsters. For the BJP-led Mahayuti, the alleged Kumbh Mela scam is a potentially damaging test of political credibility and an unwelcome headache for Minister Girish Mahajan. The arrest of Tanay Mahajan, described as a distant relative of the Minister, in an alleged racket involving fake Kumbh work orders has handed the Opposition an opportunity it will be eager to exploit. The scale of the alleged fraud makes the matter particularly serious. Police say fake work orders were shown for projects worth around Rs. 591 crore and that those who came forward were allegedly cheated of Rs. 305 crore. One complainant alone is said to have lost Rs. 2.17 crore. The documents allegedly bore the Government of India emblem and the name of the Nashik-Trimbakeshwar Kumbh Mela Authority. Mahajan has sought to distance himself from the accused, calling him a “gone case” and saying criminal cases had previously been registered against him. He has also urged strict action against everyone involved. But politically, the Minister’s proximity to one of the accused makes the episode difficult to quarantine as an ordinary fraud case. The Fadnavis government’s larger problem is one of perception. The Kumbh Mela is one of Maharashtra’s biggest public undertakings, involving enormous expenditure, infrastructure contracts and administrative machinery. If fake work orders worth hundreds of crores could circulate convincingly enough to extract money from contractors, questions will inevitably be asked about the safeguards surrounding the real tendering process. Mahajan’s clarification that Kumbh tenders are processed online, and that genuine work orders are not issued in the names of individual officials or accompanied by unauthorised QR codes, raises the obvious question: why did the alleged racket find enough room to operate in the first place? The timing makes the political challenge sharper. The Kumbh controversy comes on the heels of allegations surrounding the recent theft of Ram Mandir donations in a BJP-ruled state. A succession of controversies can create a narrative about institutional laxity on part of the ruling party at the Centre and in Maharashtra. The answer must be radical transparency. The police must follow the money, identify everyone who prepared or circulated the forged documents and establish whether anyone inside the system enabled the racket. The government should simultaneously publish a clear account of Kumbh tenders, safeguards and authorisations. The Kumbh should be an exercise in public administration, not an invitation to private profiteering. If the Mahayuti wants to prevent this alleged scam from snowballing into a larger political embarrassment, it must demonstrate that the state and not its middlemen, is in charge.

The Fight Against Child Trafficking

AI generated image
AI generated image

As we commemorate International Day Against Trafficking in Persons, let’s think about the many children who tend to get trafficked across borders. They are often lured by promises of education, employment or a better future. While public attention understandably focuses on rescue operations and criminal prosecutions yet by the time a child has disappeared, communities and institutions have already failed.


If we are to be serious about ending child-trafficking, our greatest investment should not begin with rescue but it should begin with prevention itself.


This may seem obvious, but it is a lesson that policy and practice often overlook. Discussions around trafficking frequently revolve around police action, interstate coordination and stronger laws. These are essential. However, trafficking is rarely just a law enforcement problem. It is a symptom of deeper vulnerabilities—poverty, interrupted education, unsafe migration, gender inequality, limited livelihood opportunities and the absence of community-based protection systems. And traffickers understand these vulnerabilities better than anyone else.


Contrary to popular perception, they do not always operate as strangers lurking in the shadows. They often arrive as neighbours, relatives, acquaintances or increasingly through social media. They recognise families struggling after failed harvests, adolescents forced to leave school and young people desperate to contribute to household incomes. Their greatest weapon is not force but false hope.


I would like to share the story of Surguja district in Chhattisgarh and how it demonstrates that why prevention deserves far greater attention. For years, Surguja was known as one of the state’s vulnerable source districts for child trafficking. Children quietly left villages believing they were travelling towards opportunity. Many families never reported disappearances because they assumed little could be done.


Trafficking became normalised, almost invisible. What changed was not merely policing. Communities themselves became part of the child protection system. The Village Child Protection Committees (VCPCs) started tracking school dropouts and vulnerable families. Teachers followed up on prolonged absences instead of treating them as routine. Anganwadi workers, Panchayat representatives and adolescent groups began discussing trafficking openly. Even shopkeepers, tea vendors and bus stand workers learnt to identify suspicious movement of children and alert authorities.


The result was not simply greater awareness. It was a new social norm where protecting children became everyone’s responsibility rather than the burden of individual families. The rescue of two teenage sisters from Surguja in 2022 illustrates this transformation. Lured through online promises of employment, they travelled over 1,300 kilometres towards Gurugram. Their safe return was possible because villagers immediately informed frontline workers, after which an FIR was registered without delay, community protection mechanisms activated quickly and different institutions coordinated effectively. Only a few years earlier, such an outcome would have been far less likely.


The lesson extends well beyond one district. Trafficking patterns are evolving rapidly. Social media now enables recruiters to establish trust without ever entering a village. Adolescents increasingly navigate digital spaces with little guidance on recognising manipulation or fraudulent job offers. Prevention today therefore requires digital literacy alongside traditional awareness campaigns. Parents, teachers and communities must understand that online conversations can become the first step in a trafficking chain.


Equally important is education. Children who remain in school are less vulnerable to trafficking not simply because they are occupied, but because schools provide protective relationships, access to welfare schemes and adults who notice when children disappear.


Keeping children enrolled must therefore be viewed as a child protection strategy as much as an educational objective. This also demands greater convergence across departments responsible for education, women and child development, rural livelihoods, labour, police and local governance.


Trafficking exploits institutional gaps. Prevention succeeds only when institutions work together before crises emerge. The numbers matter, but they tell only part of the story. Real change happens when communities refuse to accept exploitation as inevitable. It happens when parents question suspicious job offers, when adolescents recognise online grooming, when teachers visit homes after repeated absences and when local elected representatives treat child protection as a standing agenda rather than an emergency response.


On this World Day Against Trafficking in Persons, the most important question is not how many children we have rescued this year but how many children never had to be rescued because communities, schools and local institutions protected them before traffickers could act. That is the shift India needs.


Rescue will always remain essential. But lasting success will be measured not by the number of children brought home, but by the number who never disappear in the first place.


(The writer is the General Manager (Programs), Child Rights and You – CRY, West)

Comments

bottom of page