top of page

By:

Dr. Abhilash Dawre

19 March 2025 at 5:18:41 pm

Shinde, Chavan under fire over silence

Dombivli: The brutal assault on two doctors, alleged intimidation of nurses, and chaos inside Shastrinagar Hospital by Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre and his associates has sparked outrage across Maharashtra's medical fraternity. While a court has remanded the corporator and three others to police custody till July 13, the silence of Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and BJP Maharashtra President and Dombivli MLA Ravindra Chavan has become a major point of concern among healthcare...

Shinde, Chavan under fire over silence

Dombivli: The brutal assault on two doctors, alleged intimidation of nurses, and chaos inside Shastrinagar Hospital by Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre and his associates has sparked outrage across Maharashtra's medical fraternity. While a court has remanded the corporator and three others to police custody till July 13, the silence of Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and BJP Maharashtra President and Dombivli MLA Ravindra Chavan has become a major point of concern among healthcare workers, who say they expected their elected representatives to publicly stand by the medical staff after such a serious incident. Healthcare employees have questioned the silence of Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde, who has often publicly stated that women in the state are his "beloved sisters" and that injustice against them would not be tolerated. With allegations that a woman doctor was pushed and nurses were threatened during the incident, many in the health department say they expected a clear public response from him. Similarly, BJP Maharashtra President and Dombivli MLA Ravindra Chavan, known for regularly attending social, religious and public events in his constituency and responding to local issues, has neither visited Shastrinagar Hospital nor met the doctors, nurses and hospital staff following the attack. The absence of any public outreach has led to disappointment among healthcare workers. No Stand Medical staff said they had expected both leaders, who are known for raising public issues and supporting citizens, to stand firmly behind doctors and healthcare employees during such a critical situation. Instead, they say the lack of a strong public stand has left many employees feeling mentally distressed. Healthcare workers also pointed out that Ravindra Chavan had played a significant role in strengthening Shastrinagar Hospital by facilitating the availability of various medical facilities and taking initiatives for the recruitment of 90 medical staff in municipal hospitals. They believe that, following the attack on doctors at the same hospital, he should have visited the institution and offered support to the affected staff. His absence has reportedly drawn criticism not only from government healthcare workers but also from private medical practitioners. According to the allegations, doctors at Shastrinagar Hospital had decided to refer a pregnant woman to another hospital for further treatment. Following this, Shiv Sena (Shinde faction) corporator Ramesh Mhatre allegedly arrived at the hospital along with his supporters, questioning why his phone call had not been answered. He and his associates allegedly abused the doctors and assaulted Dr. Vaibhav Salunkhe and Dr. Srushti Baviskar. It is further alleged that the woman doctor was pushed, while two nurses were threatened. The entire incident was captured on the hospital's CCTV cameras, triggering widespread reactions across the state. Police have arrested corporator Ramesh Mhatre along with Ramesh Laxman Pawar (50), Prakash alias Prakash Uddhav Nikam (35), and Akshay Sharad Karande (30) in connection with the case.

The Water Safety Gap India Keeps Missing

From January 2025 to January 2026, sewage-contaminated piped water caused disease outbreaks in 26 cities across 22 states and union territories, sickening at least 5,500 people and killing 34. Sixteen state capitals were on that list.


In Gandhinagar, Gujarat’s capital, more than 150 children were hospitalised with typhoid in a single week after contaminated water entered the supply. In Bengaluru, residents of an entire layout reported diarrhoea and stomach infections after sewage contaminated drinking water lines. In Patna, residents describe tap water as so polluted that it causes itching on contact and cannot even be used to wash clothes.


These incidents were neither isolated nor the result of missing water testing standards. They happened because the gap between what water testing requires on paper and what is verified at the point of consumption has widened for years, largely unnoticed—a gap that runs through both municipal water supplies and the water sold to consumers in sealed bottles.


For much of India’s food safety conversation, water has remained a blind spot. It is neither packaged like a snack or sauce nor labelled to invite scrutiny. It arrives through pipes and taps, carrying the assumption that if it is flowing, it is probably fine.


Over the past two years, that assumption has repeatedly failed.


Infrastructure explains part of it. Ageing pipelines laid decades ago, often running alongside sewer lines without adequate separation, now serve cities whose populations have multiplied several-fold.


When a sewer line cracks under that strain, higher-pressure sewage often enters the drinking water network rather than the other way around. Nearly every outbreak across those 26 cities followed this mechanism. The fix is not mysterious. It is expensive, slow and politically unglamorous, which is why it keeps being deferred until an outbreak forces the issue.


More recently, regulators turned to water that never travels through municipal pipes. FSSAI reclassified packaged drinking water and mineral water as high-risk food, a category that already included dairy, meat and prepared foods, but not bottled water.


India’s packaged water market is vast and growing, yet until now a sector of this size had escaped the scrutiny applied to far smaller categories.


The reclassification followed the removal of mandatory Bureau of Indian Standards certification, a regulatory gap FSSAI officials acknowledged needed closing. Under the new framework, manufacturers must pass inspections before licensing and undergo annual third-party audits, subjecting bottled water to the same scrutiny historically reserved for more perishable products.


That shift matters because the perception of packaged water as a safer alternative to tap water has never been entirely accurate, and the data continues to confirm it.


Microplastics have been found in the overwhelming majority of tap water samples tested across Indian cities, and bottled water has not proved immune because source water entering bottling plants carries contamination that filtration does not always remove.


E. coli and other bacteria continue to surface in bottled products, reflecting inadequate sanitation at the source rather than failures in the bottling process. The packaging changes. The underlying water quality question often does not.


Ashwin Bhadri, Founder & CEO of Equinox Labs, sees this as the defining shift in how food safety in India must be understood over the next decade.


Water has long been treated as infrastructure rather than food, he says, and that classification gap has real consequences. Infrastructure is maintained on a budget cycle, while food safety is tested on a risk cycle—fundamentally different timelines.


Repairing a pipeline because the capital budget allows it is not the same discipline as a food manufacturer testing every batch because regulations require it.


Treating packaged water as high-risk food, as FSSAI has done for the packaged category, is the correct instinct. The harder task is extending that approach to the municipal supply serving the overwhelming majority of Indian households, many of whom have neither a packaged alternative nor any way to verify what comes out of their tap.


The deeper problem behind both the municipal outbreaks and the packaged water reclassification is one that surfaces in nearly every Indian food safety story: testing and standards exist, but verification at the point that matters remains inconsistent—whether in an apartment sump, a bottling plant drawing from a compromised borewell, or a pipeline running too close to an uninspected sewer line.


A standard not independently verified at the point of consumption exists mostly on paper, and paper has never stopped sewage from entering a pipe.


India’s relationship with water has long assumed abundance guarantees quality. It does not.


With urban populations expected to exceed 500 million by 2030 and ageing infrastructure absorbing ever greater pressure than it was designed for, the question is not how much water reaches people. It is whether anyone tested it before they drank it.


(The writer is the Founder and CEO of Equinox Labs. Views personal.)

Comments


bottom of page