top of page

By:

Correspondent

23 August 2024 at 9:59:04 pm

Safety First

The death of two people and injuries to five others after a 22-foot Ganesh idol collapsed during its arrival ceremony in Mumbai is a deeply disturbing accident. It is particularly unfortunate that such an incident should occur barely three weeks before Ganeshotsav begins on September 14. A festival that is synonymous with devotion, community and celebration must not begin under such a gloomy shadow. The incident took place in Bhuleshwar, as the idol of Bhuleshwaracha Raja was being...

Safety First

The death of two people and injuries to five others after a 22-foot Ganesh idol collapsed during its arrival ceremony in Mumbai is a deeply disturbing accident. It is particularly unfortunate that such an incident should occur barely three weeks before Ganeshotsav begins on September 14. A festival that is synonymous with devotion, community and celebration must not begin under such a gloomy shadow. The incident took place in Bhuleshwar, as the idol of Bhuleshwaracha Raja was being transported from Byculla to its pandal. Preliminary information points to the unravelling of loose nuts and bolts in the idol’s supporting frame. Whatever the final findings of the investigation, the fact remains that a structure weighing many tonnes and being moved through a crowded urban neighbourhood cannot be allowed to become a lethal hazard. The prompt mobilisation of the Mumbai Fire Brigade, Mumbai Police, traffic police, 108 ambulance service and civic ward staff deserves recognition. But emergency response, however efficient, is no substitute for prevention. By the time emergency services arrive, lives may already have been lost. That is the lesson Mumbai and Maharashtra must absorb before the festival begins. Ganeshotsav is among the biggest public celebrations in the state. Its arrival processions draw enormous crowds, with towering idols, decorated vehicles, music, electrical installations and devotees converging on narrow streets. The scale of the celebrations has grown dramatically, but safety practices must grow with it. Every Ganesh pandal preparing for this year’s festival should treat structural safety as seriously as religious and logistical arrangements. Frames, fasteners, lifting equipment, transport vehicles and securing mechanisms must be inspected by competent personnel before an idol is moved. Organisers should not assume that a structure is safe simply because it has been used before. A single loose bolt can have catastrophic consequences. The authorities, too, cannot leave safety entirely to organisers. Civic agencies should conduct systematic inspections of large idols and their transportation arrangements, particularly where processions pass through densely populated areas. Traffic management, crowd control, overhead electrical infrastructure and emergency access routes need to be planned in advance. Safety checks should be mandatory, documented and meaningful, not just a box-ticking exercise. There is still time to act. The accident should be treated not merely as an isolated mishap but as a warning. Maharashtra has barely three weeks to ensure that every major pandal and procession has robust safety protocols in place. Ganeshotsav should begin with faith, excitement and the unmistakable sense of a city coming together and not with the memory of preventable deaths. The best tribute to those who lost their lives in Bhuleshwar would be to ensure that no family has to suffer such grief during the celebrations ahead.

Freebies, infiltration to dominate discourse

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee holds a child on the occassion of Eid al-Fitr in Kolkata on Saturday.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee holds a child on the occassion of Eid al-Fitr in Kolkata on Saturday.

New Delhi: In the West Bengal assembly elections, issues of illegal infiltration and freebies are set to dominate the discourse. The BJP is weaving its strategy around infiltration, while the Trinamool Congress (TMC) has countered by branding the 'Special Intensive Revision' (SIR) as the first phase of the National Register of Citizens (NRC). In this race, the TMC has been liberal in announcing free facilities, dubbed by many as ‘freebies’.


The BJP is not backing down either. Drawing from its Delhi playbook of cash-aid promises to topple the incumbent, the party is looking to loosen the TMC’s hold on power. This, despite the Supreme Court of India’s recent warning that freebies are hurdles to economic growth. The top court has urged a shift towards job creation and development.


On February 19, 2026, the Supreme Court voiced profound concern over freebies during a hearing on a Tamil Nadu electricity company case. A bench presided over by Chief Justice Surya Kant sharply remarked that freebies will stall the nation's economic progress. While states are to provide facilities for those unable to afford education or basic sustenance, freebies are primarily finding their way into the pockets of those who are already living comfortably. The court further noted that several states are burdened by heavy debt and deficits, yet continue to shower free schemes upon the public. The court opined that the focus should be on job creation and economic growth. Ultimately, the economic burden of these 'freebies' falls squarely upon the taxpayers.

Financial Aid

The politics of freebies has once again compelled the common citizen to introspect. Releasing the election manifesto, TMC chief and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee promised monthly financial aid for women upon her government's re-election: Rs 1,500 per month (Rs 18,000 annually) for general category women, and Rs 1,700 monthly (Rs 20,400 yearly) for those from Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Extending the 'Banglar Yuba-Sathi' scheme, she also pledged Rs 1,500 monthly (Rs 18,000 annually) to unemployed youth.


At the time of the last assembly elections in Delhi, political parties showered voters with grand promises to win their favour. The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) pledged to deposit Rs 2,100 monthly into women's accounts upon gaining power, while Congress promised unemployed youth Rs 8,500 monthly along with LPG cylinders at Rs 500. The BJP tightened its strategy in response, declaring Rs 2,500 monthly aid for women, two free cylinders annually on Holi and Diwali, and Rs 21,000 cash assistance for pregnant women. Ultimately, the BJP's electoral gambit paid off as it formed the government in Delhi.


In West Bengal, illegal infiltration and the SIR–NRC issue are fuelling the contest alongside freebies. Mamata Banerjee has targeted the Modi government, alleging deliberate targeting of a specific community through the SIR process, where nearly 60 lakh cases are under scrutiny, 22 lakh have been resolved, and 10 lakh names have already been deleted.


Without resorting to the word 'infiltrator', Banerjee warned that the centre would strip citizenship under the pretext of the NRC and census after the Bengal polls. Asserting that delimitation would take place after the elections, she said the BJP would not return to power, as these issues would alienate the public from the BJP. Capitalising on this, Mamata Banerjee has attempted to mobilise a particular community.


"We will not allow (Prime Minister Narendra) Modi ji to take away your voting rights. We will fight till the end to protect democracy and the rights of every citizen," Banerjee said as she addressed a crowd of thousands at Red Road on Saturday after Eid prayers.


"Bengal believes in unity. Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians - everyone lives together here. We will not allow anyone to break this social fabric," she said.


BJP’s Moves

On the other side, the BJP has already made its opening move on the electoral chessboard with the infiltration issue. On February 26, Union Home Minister Amit Shah visited Bihar's Seemanchal, Purnea, Araria, and Kishanganj, announcing during a three-day meeting a decisive step: all illegal encroachments within 10 kilometres of India's borders were to be removed. This is being hailed as a firm counter to demographic shifts in border districts, particularly Seemanchal.


The Home Ministry's campaign is heating up the West Bengal electoral arena too, given the state's extensive share of the India–Bangladesh border. From the 1971 war to today, official and parliamentary debates have highlighted this frontier as one having a severe problem of infiltration. Reports say that about 5.7 million illegal migrants have entrenched themselves here after obtaining valid documents fraudulently.


The BJP is in a mood to make the issue the central plank of its election campaign. Amit Shah has repeatedly accused the Mamata government, saying that while the centre is actively engaged in fencing the Bangladesh border, the work is being hindered because of the Mamata administration’s failure to make the necessary land available at the frontier.


In essence, the BJP is blaming the Mamata government squarely for cross-border infiltration.


The TMC manifesto and the BJP's campaign signal that freebies and infiltration will overshadow all other issues in the West Bengal elections. Both are profoundly sensitive matters: demographic shifts from infiltration imperil a nation's culture, history, and geography alike. Indian history stands as a living witness to the fact that such changes, unfolding over centuries, compelled the nation to endure the bitter agony of partition at the time of independence. On the flip side, the Supreme Court's scrutiny of freebies carries urgent consideration. All political parties, sociologists, and intellectuals dedicated to national development should engage in public discussion as to how long this race for freebies and special concessions will go on.

Comments

bottom of page